Mr. Errol and Coristine, backed by the Captain and
Ben, told how the body was found. Wilkinson and
Perrowne related their share in conveying the corpse
to Richards’ house, and Richards confirmed their
story. The coroner himself, having examined the
body, affirmed that the deceased came to his death
by a fracture of the skull, inflicted by a heavy blow
from some blunt instrument from behind, followed by
a pistol shot in front through the temple. Two
persons, evidently, were concerned in the murder.
Who were they? Matilda Nagle was sworn.
She repudiated the name of Rawdon. She testified
that a man called Harding brought her a note from her
long lost brother Steven, asking her to meet him at
the barred gate in the narrows at a certain hour late
on Monday morning. She went, but Rawdon would
not let her go beyond the barred gate, so she called
Stevy over. He came to the foot of a tree, where
Rawdon told her she must stay; and then she saw Harding
run up behind him and hit him over the head with an
iron bar, and he fell down and went to sleep.
Did Rawdon shoot him? She shivered, and didn’t
know, nor could any cross examination extract this
evidence from her. Harding knocked him down with
the iron bar, and he went to sleep, and she couldn’t
wake him. Then she went to the corpse and cried:
“Oh, Stevy, Stevy, wake up, do wake up quick,
for he’ll come again.” The court
and jury were deeply affected. Old Mr. Newberry,
the foreman of the jury, brought in the verdict to
the effect that the deceased was murdered by a blow
from an iron bar administered by one Harding, producing
fracture of the skull, and by a pistol shot in the
left temple by some unknown person. Thus the first
inquest came to an end. The second inquest would
have been a matter of difficulty, on account of the
large number of people supposed to be implicated in
Harding’s death, had not Ben Toner, who had been
called out of court, returned with three good men
and true, namely Mr. Bigglethorpe, M. Lajeunesse,
and a certain Barney Sullivan. These three parties,
moved by the entreaties of Widow Toner, had set out
early in the morning to look up the missing Ben; and
were so delighted with their success, and so tired
with their walk, that they were willing to sit on anything,
even a coroner’s jury. Accordingly, a new
jury was empanelled, consisting of Messrs. Johnson,
Newberry, and Pawkins, Bigglethorpe, Lajeunesse and
Sullivan, Errol, Wilkinson and Richards, with the Captain,
Mr. Bangs, and Squire Walker. The latter was
chosen foreman. The coroner himself acted as
clerk. Ben Toner had seen the deceased in company
with one Newcome, and had heard him addressed as Harding.
The coroner testified to having examined the body,
which exhibited no shot wound of any kind, but the
forehead was badly bruised, evidently by a stone, as
gritty particles were to be seen adhering to it, and
two table knives were still resting in the neighbourhood
of the heart. The jury examined the corpse, and,