some trades, but the persons I have with me have had
a liberal education and follow none.”
“May not he,” replied Socrates, “who
knows how to do anything that is useful be said to
know a trade?” “Yes, certainly.”
“And are not,” continued Socrates, “oatmeal,
bread, the clothes of men and women, cassocks, coats,
and other the like manufactures, things very useful?”
“Without doubt.” “And do not
the persons at your house know how to make any of
these things?” “On the contrary,”
said Aristarchus, “I believe they know how to
make all of them.” “What are you
then afraid of,” added Socrates? “Why
do you complain of poverty, since you know how to
get rich? Do not you observe how wealthy Nausicides
is become, what numerous herds he is master of, and
what vast sums he lends the Republic? Now what
made this man so rich? Why, nothing but one of
those manufactures we mentioned, that of making oatmeal.
You see, too, that Cirthes keeps all his family,
and lives at his ease upon what he has got by being
a baker. And how doth Demeas, of the village
of Colyttus, get his livelihood? By making cassocks.
What makes Menon live so comfortably? His cloak
manufacture. And are not most of the inhabitants
of Megara in good circumstances enough by the trade
which they drive of coats and short jackets?”
“I grant all this,” said Aristarchus,
“but still there is a difference betwixt these
persons and me: for, whereas, they have with
them some barbarians whom they have bought, and compel
to work what brings them in gain; I, for my part,
keep only ladies and gentlemen at my house, persons
who are free, and some of them my own relations.
Now would you have me to set them to work?”
“And because they are free and your relations,”
said Socrates, “do you think they ought to do
nothing but eat and sleep? Do you observe that
they, who live thus idle and at their ease, lead more
comfortable lives than others? Do you think
them more content, more cheerful, that is to say,
more happy than those who employ themselves in any
of those manufactures we have mentioned, or in whatever
else tends to the utility or convenience of life?
Do you imagine that idleness and laziness contribute
toward our learning things necessary; that they can
enable us to retain those things we have already learnt;
that they help to strengthen the body or keep it in
health; that they can assist us to get riches, or
keep what we have got already; and do you believe that
labour and industry are good for nothing? Why
did your ladies learn what you say they know.
Did they believe them to be useless things, and had
they resolved never to put them in practice?
Or, on the contrary, was it with design to employ
themselves in those matters, and to get something by
them? Is it a greater piece of wisdom to sit
still and do nothing, than to busy oneself in things
that are of use in life, and that turn to account?
And is it not more reasonable for a man to work than
to be with his arms across, thinking how he shall