we must then, from henceforward, abstain from speaking
as we ought; and if for the latter, it is plain that
we ought to endeavour to speak well.” At
these words Charicles flew into a passion, and said
to him: “Since you pretend to be ignorant
of things that are so easily known, we forbid you to
speak to the young men in any manner whatever.”
“It is enough,” answered Socrates; “but
that I may not be in a perpetual uncertainty, pray
prescribe to me, till what age men are young.”
“Till they are capable of being members of
the Senate,” said Charicles: “in a
word, speak to no man under thirty years of age.”
“How!” says Socrates, “if I would
buy anything of a tradesman who is not thirty years
old am I forbid to ask him the price of it?”
“I mean not so,” answered Charicles:
“but I am not surprised that you ask me this
question, for it is your custom to ask many things
that you know very well.” Socrates added:
“And if a young man ask me in the street where
Charicles lodges, or whether I know where Critias
is, must I make him no answer?” “I mean
not so neither,” answered Charicles. Here
Critias, interrupting their discourse, said:
“For the future, Socrates, you must have nothing
to do with the city tradesmen, the shoemakers, masons,
smiths, and other mechanics, whom you so often allege
as examples of life; and who, I apprehend, are quite
jaded with your discourses.” “I must
then likewise,” replied Socrates, “omit
the consequences I draw from those discourses; and
have no more to do with justice, piety, and the other
duties of a good man.” “Yes, yes,”
said Charicles; “and I advise you to meddle no
more with those that tend herds of oxen; otherwise
take care you lose not your own.” And these
last words made it appear that Critias and Charicles
had taken offence at the discourse which Socrates
had held against their government, when he compared
them to a man that suffers his herd to fall to ruin.
Thus we see how Critias frequented Socrates, and what
opinion they had of each other. I add, moreover,
that we cannot learn anything of a man whom we do
not like: therefore if Critias and Alcibiades
made no great improvement with Socrates, it proceeded
from this, that they never liked him. For at
the very time that they conversed with him, they always
rather courted the conversation of those who were employed
in the public affairs, because they had no design
but to govern.—The following conference
of Alcibiades, in particular, which he had with Pericles,
his governor—who was the chief man of the
city, whilst he was yet under twenty years of age—concerning
the nature of the laws, will confirm what I have now
advanced.