Title:  Chambers’s Edinburgh Journal, No. 432 Volume 17, New Series, April 10, 1852

Author:  Various

Editor:  Robert Chambers and William Chambers

Release Date:  December 18, 2005 [EBook #17348]

Language:  English

Character set encoding:  ASCII

*** Start of this project gutenberg EBOOK Chambers’s Edinburgh ***

Produced by Malcolm Farmer, Richard J. Shiffer and the
Online Distributed Proofreading Team.

Chambers’Edinburgh journal

Conducted by William and Robert Chambers, editors of ’Chambers’s
information for the people,’ ‘Chambers’s educational course,’ &c.

No. 432.  New series.  Saturday, April 10, 1852.  Price 1-1/2_d._

THE MEDIAEVAL MANIA.

History is said to be a series of reactions.  Society, like a pendulum, first drives one way, and then swings back in the opposite direction.  At present, we may be said to be returning at full speed towards a taste for everything old, neglected, and for ages despised.  Science and refinement have had their day, and now rude nature and the elemental are to be in the ascendant.  In our boyhood, we learned the Roman alphabet; but youngsters now had need to add a knowledge of black-letter, which is rapidly getting back into fashion.  Perfection is only to be found in the darkness and ignorance of the middle ages.

It is proper, no doubt, to get rid of what is tame and spiritless in art; and it must be owned that nearly everything that was done in architecture and decoration during the Georgian era was detestable.  But it is one thing to reform, and another to revolutionise.  Let us by all means go to nature for instruction; but nature under the exercise of cultivated feeling—­selecting what tends to ennoble and refine, not that which degrades and sends us back to forms and ideas totally out of place in the nineteenth century, and which, for that very reason, can have nothing but a temporary reign, to be followed in the succeeding age by a violent reaction.

On a former occasion, we drew attention to this tendency towards mediaevalism as regards ornamental design, and took the Great Exhibition to witness the fact.  We have also pointed to that strange phenomenon, the rise anew of monastic institutions among us, long after their object is accomplished, giving a spectre-like expression to an obsolete idea; we have exposed, likewise, the inclination of the working-classes to trust to the protection, and, on every emergency, claim as a matter of right the aid of the wealthy, thus wilfully and deliberately returning to the condition of serfdom:  we have now to trace the mediaeval mania in a department where, notwithstanding all this ominous conjunction of symptoms, its appearance is truly surprising—­in the department of high art in painting.