’Phemius, since thou knowest many other charms for mortals, deeds of men and gods, which bards rehearse, some one of these do thou sing as thou sittest by them, and let them drink their wine in silence; but cease from this pitiful strain, that ever wastes my heart within my breast, since to me above all women hath come a sorrow comfortless.  So dear a head do I long for in constant memory, namely, that man whose fame is noised abroad from Hellas to mid Argos.’

Then wise Telemachus answered her, and said:  ’O my mother, why then dost thou grudge the sweet minstrel to gladden us as his spirit moves him?  It is not minstrels who are in fault, but Zeus, methinks, is in fault, who gives to men, that live by bread, to each one as he will.  As for him it is no blame if he sings the ill-faring of the Danaans; for men always prize that song the most, which rings newest in their ears.  But let thy heart and mind endure to listen, for not Odysseus only lost in Troy the day of his returning, but many another likewise perished.  Howbeit go to thy chamber and mind thine own housewiferies, the loom and distaff, and bid thy handmaids ply their tasks.  But speech shall be for men, for all, but for me in chief; for mine is the lordship in the house.’

Then in amaze she went back to her chamber, for she laid up the wise saying of her son in her heart.  She ascended to her upper chamber with the women her handmaids, and then was bewailing Odysseus, her dear lord, till grey-eyed Athene cast sweet sleep upon her eyelids.

Now the wooers clamoured throughout the shadowy halls, and each one uttered a prayer to be her bedfellow.  And wise Telemachus first spake among them: 

’Wooers of my mother, men despiteful out of measure, let us feast now and make merry and let there be no brawling; for, lo, it is a good thing to list to a minstrel such as him, like to the gods in voice.  But in the morning let us all go to the assembly and sit us down, that I may declare my saying outright, to wit that ye leave these halls:  and busy yourselves with other feasts, eating your own substance, going in turn from house to house.  But if ye deem this a likelier and a better thing, that one man’s goods should perish without atonement, then waste ye as ye will; and I will call upon the everlasting gods, if haply Zeus may grant that acts of recompense be made:  so should ye hereafter perish within the halls without atonement.’

So spake he, and all that heard him bit their lips and marvelled at Telemachus, in that he spake boldly.

Then Antinous, son of Eupeithes, answered him:  ’Telemachus, in very truth the gods themselves instruct thee to be proud of speech and boldly to harangue.  Never may Cronion make thee king in seagirt Ithaca, which thing is of inheritance thy right!’