With his broad pennant folded over his arm, and accompanied by a younger brother and four seamen, he stepped into the small boat, which began pulling in the direction of the Niagara.  The thick smoke concealed them for a time, but it soon lifted, and Barclay aimed a shot at the boat.  He said in his official report that he saw the shot strike the boat, whereupon Perry took off his coat and plugged the hole with it.  But for the temporary veil the American commander could not have made half the brief distance between the Lawrence and the Niagara.  As it was, however, he reached the latter without a scratch.  He hoisted his pennant and the flag bearing the immortal words of the gallant Lawrence.  Then an officer was sent in a boat to communicate the orders of the Commodore to the other vessels.  This was hardly done when Perry saw with the keenest distress the surrender of the Lawrence.  Such submission was inevitable, for almost every man on board was either killed or wounded and every gun on the engaged side was disabled.  The English crews broke into cheers, believing the battle won, but they could not take possession of the Lawrence, which drifted out of range.

Captain Barclay now made an attempt to change his line of battle with a view of bringing his other broadsides into action.  The line became broken and entangled, observing which, Perry took instant advantage of it.  The Niagara, passing through the disorganized squadron, raked the vessels fore and aft, while the other American vessels promptly followed, and added to the confusion of the enemy and the dreadful destruction on board.  The Americans were now at close quarters and able to do their best work, and so dreadful was it that fifteen minutes later a white handkerchief was waved at the end of a boarding-pike on one of the boats as a signal of surrender.

Firing ceased, and in the smoke and confusion two of the enemy’s boats darted away in an attempt to escape; but they were followed and brought back.  Determined to honor the Lawrence, Perry now had himself rowed to the wreck, drifting some distance away in charge of the few that had survived the awful conflict.  Perry took his position aft and with calm dignity received the surrender.  As the defeated officers approached and presented their swords in turn, he told each to retain the weapon, accompanying the remark with words of compliment for the bravery he had displayed.

The loss of the Americans was 27 killed and 96 wounded, and that of the British 41 killed and 94 wounded.  Perry showed every possible kindness to the suffering prisoners, who expressed their gratitude.  Commander Barclay displayed conspicuous bravery throughout the battle and was twice wounded, one of his injuries depriving him of the use of his single remaining arm.