Then, in my anger I arose and went stamping up and down the room, while Tim sat there staring at me blankly.  At last I halted by the fireplace and stood there looking down at him very hard.  I looked right into his heart and read it.  He winced and turned his face from me.  I was the righteous judge now and he the culprit.

“You left her, Tim,” I said hotly.  “You might have known the girl could never marry me after that minute.  You might have known she was not the girl to deceive me—­she would have told me; and then, Tim, do you think that I would have kept her to her promise?  Why didn’t you come to me and tell me?”

“For your sake, Mark, I didn’t,” Tim answered, looking up.

“And for my sake you left the girl there—­you turned your back on her and went away.  Then in her perplexity she looked to me again, and I had gone.  I didn’t know.  I went away for her sake, and when she sent for me I had forsaken her, too.  That’s a shabby way to treat a woman.  Do you wonder she turned to Weston?”

“No,” Tim said, “for Weston is a man of men, he is—­and he cared for her—­that’s why he stayed in the valley.”

“I knew that,” said I, “for I saw it that day when he went away from me to the charcoal clearing.”

“Then think of the lonely girl up there on the hill, Mark,” Tim said.  He joined me at the fireplace, and we stood side by side, as often we had stood in the old days, warming our hands, and watching the crackling flames.  “Do you blame her?  I had gone, vowing never to come back again till she kept her promise to you; you had fled from her—­she wrote, and no word came.  And Weston is a wise man and a kind man, and when she turned to him she found comfort.  Do you blame her?”

“No,” I said, half hesitating.

“After all, it’s better, too,” Tim went on.  “What could you have given her, Mark—­or I, compared to what his wealth means to a woman like Mary?”

Wealth was not happiness.  Money was not peace.  Etches were a delusion.  Now she had them.  That was what Weston would give her, and I wished her joy.  True, he loved the girl.  True, he offered her just what I did, and with it he gave those fleeting joys that wealth brings.  She should be happy—­just as much so as if she had made herself a fellow-prisoner with me here in the little valley.  For what had I to offer her?  The love of a crippled veteran; the wealth of a petty farmer; the companionship of a crotchety pedagogue.  What joy it would give her ambitious soul as the years went on to watch her husband develop; to see him growing in the learning of the store; to have him ranking first among the worthies of the bench; to greet him as he hobbled home at night after a busy day at nothing!  It was better as it was—­aye—­a thousand times.

But there was Tim.  What a man Tim was, and how blind I had been and selfish!  He stood before me tall and strong, watching me with his quiet eyes, and as I looked at him I thought of Weston, the lanky cynic, with his thin, homely face and loose-jointed, shambling walk.  Then I wondered at it all.  Then I said to myself, “Is it best?”