In 1209 the Pope proceeded to the further sentence of excommunication, and the king was formally cut off from the pale of the Church.  But the new sentence was met with the same defiance as the old.  Five of the bishops fled over sea, and secret disaffection was spreading widely, but there was no public avoidance of the excommunicated king.  An Archdeacon of Norwich who withdrew from his service was crushed to death under a cope of lead, and the hint was sufficient to prevent either prelate or noble from following his example.

[Sidenote:  The Deposition]

The attitude of John showed the power which the administrative reforms of his father had given to the Crown.  He stood alone, with nobles estranged from him and the Church against him, but his strength seemed utterly unbroken.  From the first moment of his rule John had defied the baronage.  The promise to satisfy their demand for redress of wrongs in the past reign, a promise made at his election, remained unfulfilled; when the demand was repeated he answered it by seizing their castles and taking their children as hostages for their loyalty.  The cost of his fruitless threats of war had been met by heavy and repeated taxation, by increased land tax and increased scutage.  The quarrel with the Church and fear of their revolt only deepened his oppression of the nobles.  He drove De Braose, one of the most powerful of the Lords Marchers, to die in exile, while his wife and grandchildren were believed to have been starved to death in the royal prisons.  On the nobles who still clung panic-stricken to the court of the excommunicate king John heaped outrages worse than death.  Illegal exactions, the seizure of their castles, the preference shown to foreigners, were small provocations compared with his attacks on the honour of their wives and daughters.  But the baronage still submitted.  The financial exactions indeed became light as John filled his treasury with the goods of the Church; the king’s vigour was seen in the rapidity with which he crushed a rising of the nobles in Ireland, and foiled an outbreak of the Welsh; while the triumphs of his father had taught the baronage its weakness in any single-handed struggle against the Crown.  Hated therefore as he was the land remained still.  Only one weapon was now left in Innocent’s hands.  Men held then that a king, once excommunicate, ceased to be a Christian or to have any claims on the obedience of Christian subjects.  As spiritual heads of Christendom, the Popes had ere now asserted their right to remove such a ruler from his throne and to give it to a worthier than he; and it was this right which Innocent at last felt himself driven to exercise.  After useless threats he issued in 1212 a bull of deposition against John, absolved his subjects from their allegiance, proclaimed a crusade against him as an enemy to Christianity and the Church, and committed the execution of the sentence to the king of the French.  John met the