“I was too
anxious to seize on the opportunity thus offered of
giving the book a fair
chance with the multitudinous readers of
the Times to
make any difficulty about conditions; and being
then very full of the
subject, I wrote the article faster, I
think, than I ever wrote
anything in my life, and sent it to Mr.
Lucas, who duly prefixed
his opening sentences. When the article
appeared, there was
much speculation as to its authorship. The
secret leaked out in
time, as all secrets will, but not by my
aid; and then I used
to derive a good deal of innocent amusement
from the vehement assertions
of some of my more acute friends,
that they knew it was
mine from the first paragraph.” “As
the
Times some years
since referred to my connection with the
review, I suppose there
will be no breach of confidence in the
publication of this
little history.”
This review was one of the few favourable notices, and naturally it delighted Darwin greatly. He wrote to Hooker about it: “Have you seen the splendid essay and notice of my book in the Times? I cannot avoid a strong suspicion that it is by Huxley; but I have never heard that he wrote in the Times. It will do grand service.” On the same day, writing to Huxley himself, he said of the review:
“It included an eulogium of me which quite touched me, although I am not vain enough to think it all deserved. The author is a literary man and a German scholar. He has read my book attentively; but, what is very remarkable, it seems that he is a profound naturalist. He knows my barnacle book and appreciates it too highly. Lastly, he writes and thinks with quite uncommon force and clearness; and, what is even still rarer, his writing is seasoned with most pleasant wit. We all laughed heartily over some of the sentences.... Who can it be? Certainly I should have said that there was only one man in England who could have written this essay, and that you were the man; but I suppose that I am wrong, and that there is some hidden genius of great calibre; for how could you influence Jupiter Olympus and make him give you three and a half columns to pure science? The old fogies will think the world will come to an end. Well, whoever the man is, he has done great service to the cause.”
The essay in the Times was followed shortly afterwards by a “Friday Evening Discourse” in 1860 on “Species, Races, and their Origin,” in which Huxley, addressing a cultivated audience, laid the whole weight of his brilliant scientific