bankers, who are to take the foreign, home, and financial
departments respectively. How they are to conduct
the government and remain bankers, does not clearly
appear; but it must be intended that they should combine
both offices, for they are to receive no pecuniary
remuneration for the political one. Their power
is to amount to a dictatorship (M. Comte’s
own word): and he is hardly justified in saying
that he gives political power to the rich, since he
gives it over the rich and every one else, to three
individuals of the number, not even chosen by the
rest, but named by their predecessors. As a check
on the dictators, there is to be complete freedom of
speech, writing, printing, and voluntary association;
and all important acts of the government, except in
cases of emergency, are to be announced sufficiently
long beforehand to ensure ample discussion. This,
and the influences of the Spiritual Power, are the
only guarantees provided against misgovernment.
When we consider that the complete dominion of every
nation of mankind is thus handed over to only four
men—for the Spiritual Power is to be under
the absolute and undivided control of a single Pontiff
for the whole human race—one is appalled
at the picture of entire subjugation and slavery,
which is recommended to us as the last and highest
result of the evolution of Humanity. But the conception
rises to the terrific, when we are told the mode in
which the single High Priest of Humanity is intended
to use his authority. It is the most warning
example we know, into what frightful aberrations a
powerful and comprehensive mind may be led by the
exclusive following out of a single idea.
The single idea of M. Comte, on this subject, is that
the intellect should be wholly subordinated to the
feelings; or, to translate the meaning out of sentimental
into logical language, that the exercise of the intellect,
as of all our other faculties, should have for its
sole object the general good. Every other employment
of it should be accounted not only idle and frivolous,
but morally culpable. Being indebted wholly to
Humanity for the cultivation to which we owe our mental
powers, we are bound in return to consecrate them wholly
to her service. Having made up his mind that
this ought to be, there is with M. Comte but one step
to concluding that the Grand Pontiff of Humanity must
take care that it shall be; and on this foundation
he organizes an elaborate system for the total suppression
of all independent thought. He does not, indeed,
invoke the arm of the law, or call for any prohibitions.
The clergy are to have no monopoly. Any one else
may cultivate science if he can, may write and publish
if he can find readers, may give private instruction
if anybody consents to receive it. But since
the sacerdotal body will absorb into itself all but
those whom it deems either intellectually or morally
unequal to the vocation, all rival teachers will,
as he calculates, be so discredited beforehand, that