And so popular is an enterprise on that country in
this, that we had only to lie still, and he would
have had followers enough to have been in the city
of Mexico in six weeks. You have doubtless seen
my several messages to Congress, which gave a faithful
narrative of that conspiracy. Burr himself, after
being disarmed by our endeavors of all his followers,
escaped from the custody of the court of Mississippi,
but was taken near Fort Stoddart, making his way to
Mobile, by some country people, who brought him on
as a prisoner to Richmond, where he is now under a
course for trial. Hitherto we have believed our
law to be, that suspicion on probable grounds was
sufficient cause to commit a person for trial, allowing
time to collect witnesses till the trial. But
the judges here have decided, that conclusive evidence
of guilt must be ready in the moment of arrest, or
they will discharge the malefactor. If this is
still insisted on, Burr will be discharged; because
his crimes having been sown from Maine, through the
whole line of the western waters, to New Orleans, we
cannot bring the witnesses here under four months.
The fact is, that the federalists make Burr’s
cause their own, and exert their whole influence to
shield him from punishment, as they did the adherents
of Miranda. And it is unfortunate that federalism
is still predominent in our judiciary department,
which is consequently in opposition to the legislative
and executive branches, and is able to baffle their
measures often.
Accept my friendly salutations, and assurances of
great esteem and respect.
Th: Jefferson.
LETTER XLIII.—TO WILLIAM B. GILES, April 20, 1807
TO WILLIAM B. GILES.
Monticello, April 20, 1807.
Dear Sir,
Your favor of the 6th instant, on the subject of Burr’s
offences, was received only four days ago. That
there should be anxiety and doubt in the public mind,
in the present defective state of the proof, is not
wonderful; and this has been sedulously encouraged
by the tricks of the judges to force trials before
it is possible to collect the evidence, dispersed
through a line of two thousand miles from Maine to
Orleans. The federalists, too, give all their
aid, making Burr’s cause their own, mortified
only that he did not separate the union or overturn
the government, and proving, that had he had a little
dawn of success, they would have joined him to introduce
his object, their favorite monarchy, as they would
any other enemy, foreign or domestic, who could rid
them of this hateful republic for any other government
in exchange.