When the laws have declared and enforced all this,
they have fulfilled their functions, and the idea
is quite unfounded, that on entering into society
we give up any natural right. The trial of every
law by one of these texts, would lessen much the labors
of our legislators, and lighten equally our municipal
codes. There is a work of the first order of
merit now in the press at Washington, by Destutt Tracy,
on the subject of political economy, which he brings
into the compass of three hundred pages, octavo.
In a preliminary discourse on the origin of the right
of property, he coincides much with the principles
of the present manuscript; but is more developed,
more demonstrative. He promises a future work
on morals, in which I lament to see, that he will adopt
the principles of Hobbes, or humiliation to human
nature; that the sense of justice and injustice is
not derived from our natural organization, but founded
on convention only. I lament this the more, as
he is unquestionably the ablest writer living, on
abstract subjects. Assuming the fact, that the
earth has been created in time, and consequently the
dogma of final causes, we yield, of course, to this
short syllogism. Man was created for social intercourse;
but social intercourse cannot be maintained without
a sense of justice; then man must have been created
with a sense of justice. There is an error into
which most of the speculators on government have fallen,
and which the well known state of society of our Indians
ought, before now, to have corrected. In their
hypothesis of the origin of government, they suppose
it to have commenced in the patriarchal or monarchical
form. Our Indians are evidently in that state
of nature which has passed the association of a single
family; and not yet submitted to the authority of positive
laws, or of any acknowledged magistrate. Every
man, with them, is perfectly free to follow his own
inclinations. But if, in doing this, he violates
the rights of another, if the case be slight, he is
punished by the disesteem of his society, or, as we
say, by public opinion; if serious, he is tomahawked
as a dangerous enemy. Their leaders conduct them
by the influence of their character only; and they
follow, or not, as they please, him of whose character
for wisdom or war they have the highest opinion.
Hence the origin of the parties among them adhering
to different leaders, and governed by their advice,
not by their command. The Cherokees, the only
tribe I know to be contemplating the establishment
of regular laws, magistrates, and government, propose
a government of representatives, elected from every
town. But of all things, they least think of
subjecting themselves to the will of one man.
This, the only instance of actual fact within our knowledge,
will be then a beginning by republican, and not by
patriarchal or monarchical government, as speculative
writers have generally conjectured.