a government by a plurality, as of temporary trusts
of power in a single hand rendered permanent by usurpation.
I do not believe, therefore, that this danger is lessened
in the hands of a plural executive. Perhaps it
is greatly increased, by the state of inefficiency
to which they are liable from feuds and divisions
among themselves. The conservative body you propose
might be so constituted, as, while it would be an admirable
sedative in a variety of smaller cases, might also
be a valuable sentinel and check on the liberticide
views of an ambitious individual. I am friendly
to this idea. But the true barriers of our liberty
in this country are our State governments: and
the wisest conservative power ever contrived by man,
is that of which our Revolution and present government
found us possessed. Seventeen distinct States,
amalgamated into one as to their foreign concerns,
but single and independent as to their internal administration,
regularly organized with a legislature and governor
resting on the choice of the people, and enlightened
by a free press, can never be so fascinated by the
arts of one man, as to submit voluntarily to his usurpation.
Nor can they be constrained to it by any force he
can possess. While that may paralyze the single
State in which it happens to be encamped, sixteen
others, spread over a country of two thousand miles
diameter, rise up on every side, ready organized for
deliberation by a constitutional legislature, and for
action by their governor, constitutionally the commander
of the militia of the State, that is to say, of every
man in it, able to bear arms; and that militia, too,
regularly formed into regiments and battalions, into
infantry, cavalry, and artillery, trained under officers
general and subordinate, legally appointed, always
in readiness, and to whom they are already in habits
of obedience. The republican government of France
was lost without a struggle, because the party of
‘un et indivisible’ had prevailed:
no provincial organizations existed to which the people
might rally under authority of the laws, the seats
of the directory were virtually vacant, and a small
force sufficed to turn the legislature out of their
chamber and to salute its leader chief of the nation.
But with us, sixteen out of seventeen States rising
in mass, under regular organization and legal commanders,
united in object and action by their Congress, or,
if that be in duresse, by a special convention, present
such obstacles to an usurper as for ever to stifle
ambition in the first conception of that object.
Dangers of another kind might more reasonably be apprehended from this perfect and distinct organization, civil and military, of the States; to wit, that certain States, from local and occasional discontents, might attempt to secede from the Union. This is certainly possible; and would be befriended by this regular organization. But it is not probable that local discontents can spread to such an extent, as to be