may thus account for a few words to be found in them
which were introduced at a later period. [547:3] Their
tone and spirit, which are entirely different from
the spurious productions ascribed to the same age,
plead strongly in their favour as trustworthy witnesses.
The writer makes no lofty pretensions as a Roman bishop;
he speaks of himself simply as at the head of an humble
presbytery; and it would be difficult to divine the
motive which could have tempted an impostor to fabricate
such unpretending compositions. Though given as
the veritable Epistles of Pius by the highest literary
authorities of Borne, they are certainly ill calculated
to prop up the cause of the Papacy. If their
claims are admitted, they must be regarded as among
the earliest authentic records in which the distinction
between the terms bishop and presbyter is unequivocally
recognized; and it is obvious that if alterations
in the ecclesiastical constitution were made under
Hyginus, they must have prepared the way for such
a change in the terminology. In one of these
Epistles Pius gives the following piece of advice to
his correspondent:—“Let the elders
and deacons respect you, not as a greater,
but as the servant of Christ.” [548:1] This letter
purports to have been written when its author anticipated
the approach of death; and the individual to whom
it is directed seems to have been just placed in the
episcopal chair. Had Pius believed that Justus
had a divine right to rule over the presbyters, would
he have tendered such an admonition? A hundred
years afterwards, Cyprian of Carthage, when addressing
a young prelate, would certainly have expressed himself
very differently. He would, probably, have complained
of the presumption of the presbyters, have boasted
of the majesty of the episcopate, and have exhorted
the new bishop to remember his apostolical dignity.
But, in the middle of the second century, such language
would have been strangely out of place. Pius
is writing to an individual, just entering on an office
lately endowed with additional privileges, who could
not yet afford to make an arbitrary use of his new
authority. He, therefore, counsels him to moderation,
and cautions him against presuming on his power.
“Beware,” says he, “in your intercourse
with your presbyters and deacons, of insisting too
much on the duty of obedience. Let them feel that
your prerogative is not exercised capriciously, but
for good and necessary purposes. Let the elders
and deacons regard you, not so much in the light of
a superior, as the servant of Christ.”
In another portion of this letter a piece of intelligence is communicated, which, as coming from Pius, possesses peculiar interest. When the law was enacted altering the mode of succession to the presidency, it may be supposed that the proceeding was deemed somewhat ungracious towards those aged presbyters who might have soon expected, as a matter of right, to obtain possession of the seat of the moderator. The death of Telesphorus, the