sufficient cause; not so, however, the Persons who
had the best means of ascertaining the state of the
Country; for they could have been induced to have recourse
to a measure, at all times so obnoxious, by nothing
less than a persuasion of its expediency. ’But
persuasion (an Objector will say) is produced in many
ways; and even that degree of it which in these matters
passes for conviction, depends less upon external testimony
than on the habits and feelings of those by whom the
testimony is to be weighed and decided upon.
A council for the administration of affairs is far
from being as favourably circumstanced as a tribunal
of law; for the Party, which is to pronounce upon
the case, has had to procure the evidence, the sum
and quality of which must needs have been affected
by previously existing prejudices, and by any bias
received in the process of collecting it.—The
privileges of the subject, one might think, would
never be unjustifiably infringed, if it were only from
considerations of self-interest; but power is apt
to resort to unnecessary rigour in order to supply
the deficiencies of authority forfeited by remissness;
it is also not unfrequently exerted merely to shew
that it is possessed; to shew this to others while
power is a novelty, and when it has long ceased to
be so, to prove it to ourselves. Impatience of
mind, moreover, puts men upon the use of strong and
coarse tools, when those of lighter make and finer
edge, with due care, might execute the work much better.
Above all, timidity flies to extremes;—if
the elements were at our command, how often would
an inundation be called for, when a fire-engine would
have proved equal to the service!—Much more
might be urged in this strain, and similar suggestions
are all that the question will admit of; for to suppose
a gross appetite of tyranny in Government, would be
an insult to the reader’s understanding.
Happily for the Inhabitants of Westmoreland, as no
dispositions existing among them could furnish a motive
for this restrictive measure, so they will not be
sorry that their remoteness from scenes of public confusion,
has placed them where they will be slow to give an
unqualified opinion upon its merits. Yet it will
not escape their discernment, that, if doubts might
have been entertained whether the ignorant and distressed
multitude, in other parts of the Island, were actually
brought to a state that justified the suspension of
this law, such doubts must have been weakened, if
not wholly removed, by the subsequent behaviour of
those in the upper ranks of society, who, in order
to arraign the Government, and denounce the laws,
have seized every opportunity of palliating sedition,
if not of exculpating treason. O far better to
employ bad men in the detection of foul conspiracies,
than to excuse and shelter—(would that
I were allowed to confine myself to these words)—than
to reward and honour—every one that can
contrive to make himself conspicuous by courses which,
wherever they are not branded with infamy, find the
national character in a state of degradation, ominous
(if it should spread) for the existence of all that
ought to be dear to Englishmen.