with the applause of contemporaries but the ridicule
of posterity; to the whole nation ease without dignity
and facilities for sinking tranquilly into corruption;
then no period of her history was so felicitous for
Italy as the 140 years which followed the peace of
Cateau-Cambresis. Invasions ceased: her foreign
lord saved Italy from intermeddling rivals. Internal
struggles ceased: her foreign lord removed their
causes and curbed national ambitions. Popular
revolutions ceased: her foreign lord bitted and
bridled the population of her provinces. Of bravi,
highwaymen, vulgar acts of vengeance, tragedies among
nobles and princes, we find indeed abundance; but these
affected the mass of the people to no serious extent.
The Italians enjoyed life, indulged in the sweets
of leisure, the sweets of vice, the sweets of making
love and dangling after women. From the camp and
the council-chamber, where they had formerly been
bred, the nobles passed into petty courts and moldered
in a multitude of little capitals. Men bearing
historic names, insensible of their own degradation,
bowed the neck gladly, groveled in beatitude.
Deprived of power, they consoled themselves with privileges,
patented favors, impertinences vented on the common
people. The princes amused themselves by debasing
the old aristocracy to the mire, depreciating their
honors by the creations of new titles, multiplying
frivolous concessions, adding class to class of idle
and servile dependents on their personal bounty.
In one word, the paradise of mediocrities came into
being.’
Tasso was born before the beginning of this epoch.
But he lived into the last decade of the sixteenth
century. In every fiber of his character he felt
the influences of Italian decadence, even while he
reacted against them. His misfortunes resulted
in great measure from his not having wholly discarded
the traditions of the Renaissance, though his temperament
and acquired habits made him in many points sympathetic
to the Counter-Reformation. At the same time,
he was not a mediocrity, but the last of an illustrious
race of nobly gifted men of genius. Therefore
he never patiently submitted to the humiliating conditions
which his own conception of the Court, the Prince,
the Church, and the Italian gentleman logically involved
at that period. He could not be contented with
the paradise of mediocrities described by Balbi.
Yet he had not strength to live outside its pale.
It was the pathos of his situation that he persisted
in idealizing this paradise, and expected to find
in it a paradise of exceptional natures. This
it could not be. No one turns Circe’s pigsty
into a Parnassus. If Tasso had possessed force
of character enough to rend the trammels of convention
and to live his own life in a self-constructed sphere,
he might still have been unfortunate. Nature
condemned him to suffering. But from the study
of his history we then had risen invigorated by the
contemplation of heroism, instead of quitting it,
as now we do, with pity, but with pity tempered by
a slight contempt.