“It must be remembered that the witnesses Hugo, Matthijsen, Van Wijk and de Klerk are all accomplices, and therefore their evidence must be received with caution, especially after the curiously minute details they give on some points. It is also worthy of note that Matthijsen was not examined on the fourth charge, though he was present with Kritzinger at the time.
“The shooting
of these prisoners was absolutely unjustifiable and
illegal, and all concerned
must be held equally responsible.
“Wessels took
over the command of Kritzinger’s commando when
the
latter was wounded.
“As regards the
proclamation, the only name mentioned in it is that
of Kritzinger, and the
proclamation is signed by him. The names of
any of the other commandants
are not mentioned in it at all.
“As regards the
witnesses for the prosecution, there are three who
have been deported,
and therefore could not be obtained.”
Address by the Counsel for the Defence.
(Advocate H.G. Gardiner.)
“Mr. President and Members of the Military Court:—
“We are now reaching
the end of a great trial, the great trial of a
great man. Of all
the trials that have been held before Military
Courts in this country,
this, I may fairly say, is most important.
“No officer of higher or even equal rank to him, who was once Chief Commandant in this Colony, has yet been tried, and on this trial much will depend. It is a case the result of which may have great and far-reaching influence. It may influence greatly the Boer commandoes in the field. On the verdict now given in his case the attitude of other leaders will greatly depend. I do not urge this upon you that you should acquit the prisoner. I do not ask you to consider the consequences of the verdict you may bring in. I know that you will bring in whatever verdict you think right regardless of all consequences, but I do bring these facts before you as a reason why you should carefully consider the evidence.
“The charge in this case is the charge of murder, the greatest crime that can be brought against a man. It is a crime of which a man cannot be technically guilty. You must have the most convincing evidence before you, and the clearest proof. It is a crime where intent must be clearly proved; where intent is essential. A merchant whose agent enters into a contract may be held responsible to carry out that contract, but a merchant whose clerk commits