and broke faith immediately—for the Indians
do not possess it. And even after he had participated
in their bestial ceremonies of drawing blood and drinking
the blood—a token of constancy among the
Indians—the latter, it was found, failed
to observe them just as readily as the friendship
had been confirmed by these customs. The commander
began to suffer almost extreme want, for already he
had provisions for but two days, and was compelled
to seek them. Hitherto efforts, such as men of
so generous souls and so desirous of peace could make,
had been made. But the Spaniards saw that they
were not advantaged, and that need was tightening
the cords, so that, if they did not look for food
in a different manner, they would doubtless perish
at the hands of the Indians, a thing quite opposed
to charity. Hence, it was permitted the Spaniards,
in order to sustain life, to take food by harsh means,
since indeed kind measures did not suffice. Nevertheless,
the commander, to be justified, took counsel with
all the others before doing anything of importance,
for he would rather err with the advice of all, than
succeed through his own single action. He called
a council of war; he communicated to all the condition
of affairs, and what efforts had been made with the
Indians in order to make firm peace, and to buy from
them with money the food necessary for their sustenance.
This, he said, it was impossible to negotiate with
the Indians. Now necessity forced the Spaniards
to get food by severer methods, since the Indians had
repulsed mild measures so obstinately. When the
commander stopped speaking, he ordered every one to
express his opinion. Thereupon, the father prior,
Fray Andres de Urdaneta, arose and spoke first, as
was his custom, because of his experience and his offices,
and because all the Spaniards regarded him as a father,
from whom must originate the remedy. He said
that natural law conceded to them the right to get
provisions by the readiest means, in order that that
fleet, which had been constructed for the good of those
barbarians, might not perish. Even if the end
of their coming had not been so great and important
to those peoples, it was a well-known wrong to refuse
them the intercourse most natural to men, without the
Spaniards having given any occasion for it. Inasmuch
as they were reduced to the preservation of life itself,
they were justified in taking arms, wherewith to get
the sustenance that the Indians had unjustly withheld
from them and refused them for their money. Quibus
necessarium tunc est bellum. Therefore, he
considered war justifiable, since by no other way
had any remedy been found among those unreasoning
barbarians. But before commencing war, he said,
a solemn declaration of the wrongs should be made,
of which the Spaniards would be, in no manner, guilty,
since they had labored so sincerely for peace and
harmony. Father Urdaneta’s advice was concurred
in unanimously, as was usual. Accordingly, his
advice was followed on this occasion, as being the
sanest and most sensible.