a batch for three months at the temperature of freezing
water, he succeeded in completely changing every individual
of the summer generation into the winter form.
The reverse of this experiment also was attempted by
Weismann. He took a female of bryoniae,
an alpine and arctic variety of Pieris napi,
showing in an intensive degree the characters of the
spring brood. This female laid eggs the caterpillars
from which fed and pupated. The pupae although
kept through the summer in a hothouse all produced
typical bryoniae, and none of these with one
exception appeared until the next year, for in the
alpine and arctic regions this species is only single-brooded.
Weismann experimented also with a small vanessid butterfly,
Araschnia levana, common on the European continent,
though unknown in our islands, which is double (or
at times treble) brooded, its spring form (levana)
alternating with a larger and more brightly coloured
summer form (prorsa). Here again by refrigerating
the summer pupae, butterflies were reared most of which
approached the winter pattern, but it was impossible
by heating the winter pupae to change levana
into prorsa. Experiments with North American
dimorphic species have given similar results.
Weismann argued from these experiments that the winter
form of these seasonally dimorphic species is in all
cases the older, and that the butterflies developing
within the summer pupae can be made to revert to the
ancestral condition by repeating the low-temperature
stimulus which always prevailed during the geologically
recent Ice Age. On the other hand, a high temperature
stimulus applied to one generation of the winter pupae
cannot induce the change into the summer pattern, which
has been evolved still more recently by slow stages,
as the continental climate has become more genial.
In tropical countries where instead of an alternation
of winter and summer, alternate dry and rainy seasons
prevail, somewhat similar seasonal dimorphism has been
observed among many butterflies. Not a few forms
of Precis, an African and Indian genus allied to our
Vanessa, that had long been considered distinct species
are now known, thanks to the researches of G.A.K.
Marshall (1898), to be alternating seasonal forms
of the same insect. The offspring when adult
does not closely resemble the parent; its appearance
is modified by the climatic environment of the pupa.
The experiments of Weismann just sketched in outline
show at least that the same principle holds for our
northern butterflies.
We are thus led to see from the life-story of such insects, that the course of the story is not rigidly fixed; the creature in its various stages is plastic, open to influence from its surroundings, capable of marked change in the course of generations. And so the seasonal changes in the history of the individual from egg to imago point us to changes in the age-long history of the race.