They were quelled, but not conquered.  The daring adventurer was to have a more dangerous encounter with these would-be pirates.  Some further time had passed in fruitless search.  The frigate lay careened beside a rock of a Bahaman island, some eight or ten men being at work on its barnacled sides, while the others had been allowed to go on shore.  They pretended that they wished to take a ramble in the tropical woods.  What they wished to do was to organize a more effectual mutiny, seize the ship, leave the captain and those who held with him on that island, and sail away as lawless rovers of the deep.

Under the great trees of that Spanish island, moss-grown and bowery, in a secluded spot which nature seemed to have set aside for secret counsels, the mutinous crew perfected their plans, and signed a round-robin compact which pledged all present to the perilous enterprise.  One man they needed to make their project sure.  They could not do without the carpenter.  He was at work on the vessel.  They sent him a message to come to them in the woods.  He came, heard their plans, affected to look on them favorably, but asked for a half-hour to consider the matter.  This they were not disposed to grant.  They must have an answer at once.  The carpenter looked about him; dark and resolute faces surrounded him.  Yet he earnestly declared he must have the time.  They vigorously declared he should not.  He was persistent, and in the end prevailed.  The half-hour respite was granted.

The carpenter then said that he must return to the vessel.  His absence from his work would look suspicious.  They could send a man with him to see that he kept faith.  The enterprise would be in danger if the captain noticed his absence.  The mutineers were not men of much intelligence or shrewdness, and consented to his return.  The carpenter, who had at heart no thought of joining the mutineers, had gained his point and saved the ship.  In spite of the guard upon his movements he managed to get a minute’s interview with Captain Phips, in which he told him what was afoot.

He was quickly at his post again, and under the eyes of his guard, but he had accomplished his purpose.  Captain Phips was quick to realize the danger, and called about him those who were still in the ship.  They all agreed to stand by him.  By good fortune the gunner was among them.  The energetic captain lost no time in devising what was to be done.  During the work on the ship the provisions had been taken ashore and placed in a tent, where several pieces of artillery were mounted to defend them, in case the Spaniards, to whom the island belonged, should appear.  Quickly but quietly these guns were brought back to the ship.  Then they and the other guns of the ship were loaded and brought to bear on the tent, and the gangway which connected the ship with the land was drawn on board.  No great time had elapsed, but Captain Phips was ready for his mutinous crew.