Debussy has aimed at creating a musical equivalent for the Maeterlinck ‘atmosphere,’ The score of ‘Pelleas et Melisande’ is a pure piece of musical impressionism, an experiment in musical pioneering the value of which it is difficult to judge offhand. He has wilfully abjured melody of any accepted kind and harmony conforming to any established tradition. His music moves in a world of its own, a dream-world of neutral tints, shadowy figures, and spectral passions. The dreamy unreality of the tale is mirrored in the vague floating discords of the music, and whatever the critics may say the effect is singularly striking and persuasive. At present there are no rumours of a successor to ‘Pelleas et Melisande,’ but whatever the future of Debussy may be, he at any rate deserves the credit of striking a note entirely new to the history of music.
There are many other living French composers who, if not destined to revolutionise the world of opera, have already done admirable work, and may yet win a more than local reputation. Charles Marie Widor has recently in ‘Les Pecheurs de Saint Jean’ (1905) given a worthy success to his twenty-year-old ‘Maitre Ambros.’ Navier Leroux, a pupil of Massenet, has carried on his master’s traditions, somewhat Wagnerised and generally speaking brought up to date, in ‘Astarte’ (1900), ’La Reine Fiammette’ (1903), ‘William Ratcliff’ (1906), and ‘Theodora’ (1907). Remarkable promise has been shown by Paul Dukas in ’Ariane et Barbe-Bleue’ (1907); by Camille d’Erlanger in ‘Le Fils de l’Etoile’ (1904) and ‘Aphrodite’ (1906); by Georges Marty in ‘Daria’ (1905); by Georges Huee in ‘Titania’ (1903), and by Gabriel Dupont in ’La Cabrera (1905), while a characteristic note of tender sentiment was struck by Reynaldo Hahn in ‘La Carmelite’ (1902).
Andre Messager’s name is chiefly associated in England with work of a lighter character, but it must not be forgotten that he is the composer of two of the most charming operas comiques of modern times, ’La Basoche’ (1890) and ‘Madame Chrysantheme’ (1893).