Some years later than the last named date, Peter Dinninny opened the first store kept in Oneonta.  The store then stood where the opera block now stands.  The first school-house was built soon after 1790, and stood on the rise of ground near the house of Horace Sessions, on the south side of the river.

Previous to 1816, when the Presbyterian church was built, church services were generally held in Frederick Brown’s barn.  The first clergyman who regularly preached here was the Rev. Alfred Conkey, who was settled at Milford.  Mr. Conkey is yet remembered by some of the older citizens as a very earnest and zealous man, besides being a person of liberal culture.

The first white child born in this town, or the first known to have been born in town, was Abram Houghtaling.  He was born in 1786.

John and Nicholas Beams were early settlers to the east of the village.  Elisha Shepherd came from New England at an early day and settled at Oneonta Plains.  His sons, in after years, became actively engaged in different branches of industry, and the Plains at one time bid fair to become the most prominent village in town.  It contained a hotel, a store, two churches and a distillery.

Andrew Parish was also one of the pioneers of Oneonta.  He was born in Massachusetts in 1786, and moved from Springfield here in 1808.  He settled on the south side of the river on the John Fritts farm, and afterwards on the hill near the “Round Top.”  From the latter place he moved to the farm now owned by his son Stephen, on the south side of the river.  Mr. Parish reared a large family of children, all of whom became successful farmers, and men of business.  Andrew Parish was a justice of the town for twenty years in succession.  He was also a commissioner of schools under the old system.  In 1809 he put up a brick kiln on the Elisha Shepherd farm at the Oneonta Plains, from which came the first bricks that were used in town.

Dr. Joseph Lindsay was the first physician who settled in Oneonta.  He came from Pelham, in the old county of Hampshire, Mass., in the year 1807.  Having received a liberal education in the advanced schools of his native state and at Williams College, in after years he became a teacher to many of the younger people of the country who were ambitious of extending their studies beyond the rudimentary branches taught at that time in the schools of the neighborhood.

In 1815, Frederick Bornt moved on the farm now owned and occupied by his son, on the Oneonta Creek.  He had been a soldier in the war of 1812 and had served at the battle of Plattsburg.  He came from Rensselaer county, N.Y.