I passed a miserable evening thinking of Max.  Next to Charlie, he had been my closest friend from girlhood; I had been accustomed to look to him for advice in all my difficulties, to rely upon his counsel.  I knew that people who were comparatively strangers to him thought he was almost too easy-going, and a little weak from excess of good-nature.  He was too tolerant of other folk’s failings; they said he preached mercy where severity would be more bracing and wholesome; and no doubt they thought that he judged himself as leniently; but they did not know Max.

I never knew a man harder to himself.  Charitable to others, he had no self-pity; selfish aims were impossible to him.  He who could not endure to witness even a child or an animal suffer, would have plucked out his right eye or parted with his right hand, in gospel phrase, if by doing so he could witness to the truth or spare pain to a weaker human being.  It was this knowledge of his inner life that made Max so priestly in my eyes.  I knew he was pure enough and strong enough to meet even Gladys’s demands.  Nothing but a modern Bayard would ever satisfy her fastidious taste; she would not look on a man’s stature, or on his outward beauty; such things would seem paltry to her; but he who aspired to be her lord and master must be worthy of all reverence and must have won his spurs:  so much had I learnt from my friendship with Gladys.

I pondered over Max’s words, and tried to piece the fragments of our conversation with recollections of my talks with Gladys.  I recalled much that had passed.  I endeavoured to find the clue to her downcast, troubled looks, her quenched and listless manner.  I felt dimly that some strange misunderstanding wrapped these two in a close fog.  What had brought about this chill, murky atmosphere, in which they failed to recognise each other’s meaning?  This was the mystery:  lives had often been shipwrecked from these miserable misunderstandings, for want of a word.  I felt completely baffled, and before the evening was over I could have cried with the sense of utter failure and bewilderment.  If Max’s chivalrous scruples had not tied my hands, I would have gone to Gladys boldly and asked her what it all meant; I would have challenged her truth; I would have compelled her to answer me; but I dared not break my promise.  By letter and in the spirit I would respect Max’s wishes.

But I resolved to watch:  no eyes should be so vigilant as mine.  I was determined, that nothing should escape my scrutiny; at least I was in possession of certain facts that would help me in finding the clue I wanted.  I knew now that Max loved Gladys and had tried to win her:  that he had nearly done so was also evident.  What had wrought that sudden change?  Had Captain Hamilton’s brilliant successes really dazzled her fancy and blinded her to Max’s quiet unobtrusive virtues?  Did she really and truly prefer her cousin?  This was what I had to find out, and here Max could not help me.