Cambridge, Mass. 
November 7, 1890.

Dear Mr. Whittier: 

I am afraid that in the confusion following the Save-Our-Song-Birds meeting last night, you were given my hat by mistake.  I have yours and will gladly exchange it if you will let me know when I may call on you.

May I not add that I am a great admirer of your verse?  Have you ever tried any musical comedy lyrics?  I think that I could get you in on the ground floor in the show game, as I know a young man who has written several songs which E.E.  Rice has said he would like to use in his next comic opera—­provided he can get words to go with them.

But we can discuss all this at our meeting, which I hope will be soon, as your hat looks like hell on me.

Yours respectfully,

Robert C. Benchley.

I am quite sure that this letter was mailed, as I find an entry in my diary of that date which reads: 

“Mailed a letter to J.G.  Whittier.  Cloudy and cooler.”

Furthermore, in a death-bed confession, some ten years later, one Mary F. Rourke, a servant employed in the house of Dr. Agassiz, with whom Whittier was bunking at the time, admitted that she herself had taken a letter, bearing my name in the corner of the envelope, to the poet at his breakfast on the following morning.

But whatever became of it after it fell into his hands, I received no reply.  I waited five days, during which time I stayed in the house rather than go out wearing the Whittier gray derby.  On the sixth day I wrote him again, as follows: 

Cambridge, Mass. 
Nov. 14, 1890.

Dear Mr. Whittier: 

How about that hat of mine?

Yours respectfully,

Robert C. Benchley.

I received no answer to this letter either.  Concluding that the good gray poet was either too busy or too gosh-darned mean to bother with the thing, I myself adopted an attitude of supercilious unconcern and closed the correspondence with the following terse message: 

Cambridge, Mass. 
December 4, 1890.

Dear Mr. Whittier: 

It is my earnest wish that the hat of mine which you are keeping will slip down over your eyes some day, interfering with your vision to such an extent that you will walk off the sidewalk into the gutter and receive painful, albeit superficial, injuries.

Your young friend,

Robert C. Benchley.

Here the matter ended so far as I was concerned, and I trust that biographers in the future will not let any confusion of motives or misunderstanding of dates enter into a clear and unbiased statement of the whole affair.  We must not have another Shelley-Byron scandal.

II

FAMILY LIFE IN AMERICA

PART I

The naturalistic literature of this country has reached such a state that no family of characters is considered true to life which does not include at least two hypochondriacs, one sadist, and one old man who spills food down the front of his vest.  If this school progresses, the following is what we may expect in our national literature in a year or so.