settled. Or he could attempt an appeal to the
world over the heads of the Conference. These
were wretched alternatives, against each of which
a great deal could be said. They were also very
risky,—especially for a politician.
The President’s mistaken policy over the Congressional
election had weakened his personal position in his
own country, and it was by no means certain that the
American public would support him in a position of
intransigeancy. It would mean a campaign in which
the issues would be clouded by every sort of personal
and party consideration, and who could say if right
would triumph in a struggle which would certainly not
be decided on its merits? Besides, any open rupture
with his colleagues would certainly bring upon his
head the blind passions of “anti-German”
resentment with which the public of all allied countries
were still inspired. They would not listen to
his arguments. They would not be cool enough
to treat the issue as one of international morality
or of the right governance of Europe. The cry
would simply be that, for various sinister and selfish
reasons, the President wished “to let the Hun
off.” The almost unanimous voice of the
French and British Press could be anticipated.
Thus, if he threw down the gage publicly he might be
defeated. And if he were defeated, would not the
final Peace be far worse than if he were to retain
his prestige and endeavor to make it as good as the
limiting conditions of European politics would allow,
him? But above all, if he were defeated, would
he not lose the League of Nations? And was not
this, after all, by far the most important issue for
the future happiness of the world? The Treaty
would be altered and softened by time. Much in
it which now seemed so vital would become trifling,
and much which was impracticable would for that very
reason never happen. But the League, even in
an imperfect form, was permanent; it was the first
commencement of a new principle in the government of
the world; Truth and Justice in international relations
could not be established in a few months,—they
must be born in due course by the slow gestation of
the League. Clemenceau had been clever enough
to let it be seen that he would swallow the League
at a price.
At the crisis of his fortunes the President was a
lonely man. Caught up in the toils of the Old
World, he stood in great need of sympathy, of moral
support, of the enthusiasm of masses. But buried
in the Conference, stifled in the hot and poisoned
atmosphere of Paris, no echo reached him from the
outer world, and no throb of passion, sympathy, or
encouragement from his silent constituents in all countries.
He felt that the blaze of popularity which had greeted
his arrival in Europe was already dimmed; the Paris
Press jeered at him openly; his political opponents
at home were taking advantage of his absence to create
an atmosphere against him; England was cold, critical,
and unresponsive. He had so formed his entourage