role of the bravo and bully, and that he did not intend
to fight, and resolved on the course that I would
pursue with him. Mr. Fairfax and myself then
called on Judge Barbour, and I repeated what I had
said to Mr. Fairfax, adding that it would be shameful
for two gentlemen, occupying such positions as they
in society, to fall upon each other with knives like
butchers or savages, and requesting him to dispense
with the knives, which he still refused to do.
I then looked him straight in the eye and said, well,
sir, if you insist upon those terms, we shall accept.
I saw his countenance change instantly. “His
coward lips did from their color fly;” and he
finally stammered out that he would “waive the
knife.” Without consulting you, I had determined
that if Barbour still insisted upon a conflict with
Bowie-knives I would take your place, believing that
he would not have any advantage over me in any fight
he could make; and knowing, moreover, that you had
involved yourself in the difficulty on my account,
I thought it only just for me to do so. But it
was demonstrated in the sequel that Barbour was playing
the game of bluff, and that he did not intend to fight
from the start. It was finally settled, however,
that the combat should take place as first proposed,
except that pistols only were to be used. Mr.
Fairfax and myself then commenced looking about for
a room; but in the meantime the affair had been noised
about town and we found it impossible to get one.
Mr. Fairfax then, after consulting Judge Barbour, proposed
that the meeting should take place the next morning
in Sutter County; to which I assented; and all the
terms and preliminaries were arranged and agreed upon.
At that time there were two daily lines of stages leaving
Marysville for Sacramento, and you and your friends
were to go down the Sacramento road to a point below
Bear River in advance of the stages, and I was to
select a suitable place for the meeting. Judge
Barbour and his friends were to follow us in one of
the coaches and I was to hail the driver as he approached
the place of meeting. You and your adversary
were to be stationed one hundred yards apart, each
armed with as many Colt’s revolvers as he chose
to carry; to fire upon each other at the word, and
to advance at pleasure and finish the conflict.
Our party was promptly on the ground according to agreement;
and when the first coach came in sight I hailed the
driver and found that Judge Barbour and his friends
were not aboard, and the coach passed on a little
below us and turned out of the road and stopped.
Soon after the other coach came in sight, and I again
hailed the driver, who stopped the coach, and Judge
Barbour instantly jumped out, and in a very excited
manner said that he was going forward to the other
coach, and called on the passengers “to take
notice, that if that d——d rascal”
(pointing to you) “attacked him he would kill
him.” I stepped in front of Judge Barbour
and said: Hold! Judge Field will not attack