He had still a lingering and persistent feeling that this whole amazing business was unreal; that he had been dreaming it or at least reading a meaning where there was none.  He knew that he could see trees and the stars in Hawley’s pond when there were none there.  Might not this be the same?  He had expected sometime or other to make a signal fire and give this scout voice a try-out with some simple word.  He had not expected to be aroused and called to service by its spectral, mysterious command.

What should he do?  Set it down to his own deceiving fancy and go back to his handbook?  Return to the wholesome realities of stalking and trailing which filled those engrossing pages?  Poor Peter Piper felt that he had made a sort of bold excursion from Piper’s Crossroads into the realm of miracles and that he had better not let that weird apparition over beyond the graveyard dupe and mock him.  Perhaps he had been “seein’ things.”  Yet there were the long and short flashes and they had spelled that warning message, or else he had gone out of his senses or been dreaming.  He hardly knew what to think, now that he had time to think.

His credulity soon gained the upper hand, he began to doubt his own eyes, and he was just a bit ashamed of what he was resolved to do.  At all events he would have the delight of doing it, and no one would know.  He would act just as a real scout would really act if the message was real and true.

Stealing down the creaky, boxed-in stairs, he got a lantern from the kitchen and lighted it.  The actual performance of this practical act made his experience of the last few minutes seem fanciful, unreal.  He was no longer under the spell of that ghostly column and he was not so sure that he believed in it.  To bestir himself upon the authority of such an uncanny warning seemed rather foolish.  He almost found it easier, now, to believe that he had seen some spectral thing in the graveyard.

As he emerged from the house the familiar things about him seemed to mock his vision of a warning message in the sky.  The startled chickens in the little hen-house resettled themselves comfortably on their perches as if not to be disturbed by such nonsense.  The calf resting at the end of his pegged rope arose, looked about him and lay down again as if he would not be a party to poor Peter’s absurd nocturnal enterprise.  The darkness and the vastness of the wooded country seemed to chill Peter’s hopes.  Now that the gripping spell was over he hardly knew what to think....

With his jack-knife he cut a piece from the rope which held the calf and moved the peg nearer to the animal which looked curiously on at this unexpected abridgment of its sphere of freedom.  It almost seemed to Peter that the calf was laughing at him.