and to engender tyranny; nor are examples wanting in
history of persons, who though models of virtue and
moderation in private stations, yet became the most
bloody and atrocious tyrants on their elevation to
supreme power. So great, indeed, is the fallibility
of human nature, that the very best of us are apt
to deviate from that just mean, in the adherence to
which consists virtue. All governments, therefore,
should provide against this capital defect; they should
be so constituted as not only to have in view what
should happen, but also what might; possibilities
should be contemplated as well as probabilities.
The power to do good should if possible be unlimited:
the ability to do evil, followed with the highest
responsibility, and restrained by a moral certainty
of punishment. An authority such as the governor
of this colony possesses, might be tolerated under
a despotic government; but it is a disgrace to one
that piques itself on its freedom. What plea
can be urged for encouraging excesses in our possessions
abroad, that would be visited with condign punishment
in our courts at home? Are those who quit the
habitations of their fathers, to extend the limits
and resources of the empire, deserving of no better
recompence than a total suspension of the rights and
liberties which their ancestors have bequeathed them?
Are they on their arrival in these remote shores,
to meet with no one of the institutions, which they
have been taught to cherish and to reverence?
If the want, indeed, of these institutions, of which
so many centuries have attested the wisdom, had as
yet been productive of no evil, there might be some
excuse offered for the withholding of them; but after
such a scandalous abuse of authority, the colonists
expected, and had a right to expect, that no subsequent
governor would have been appointed without the intervention
of some controlling power, which, while it should
tend to strengthen the execntive in the due discharge
of its functions, might at the same time protect the
subject in the legitimate exercise and enjoyment of
his private and personal rights. Never was there
a period since the foundation of the colony, when
the impolicy of its present form of government was
so strikingly manifest; and never, perhaps, will there
be an occasion, when the establishment of a house
of assembly, and of trial by jury, would have been
hailed with such enthusiastic joy and gratitude:
and accordingly the disappointment of the colonists
was extreme, when on the arrival of Governor Macquarie,
it was found that the same unwise and unconstitutional
power, which had been the cause of the late confusion
and anarchy was continued in all its pristine vigor;
and that he was uncontrolled even by the creation of
a council.