The political centre of interest, in the second place,
will after, as before, the passing of the Home Rule
Bill, be placed in London and not in Dublin. The
humdrum local business which under a system of Home
Rule ought to be discussed in the Irish Parliament,
may vitally concern the prosperity of every inhabitant
of Ireland, but it will not in general lend itself
to oratory, or arouse popular excitement. The
questions, on the other hand, to be discussed in the
Imperial Parliament at Westminster, as, for example,
whether Mr. Gladstone or Lord Salisbury shall be head
of the British Cabinet, whether the royal veto on
Irish legislation shall be exercised on the advice
of the English or of the Irish Ministry, are matters
which do not in reality greatly affect the happiness
of ordinary Irishmen. But they give room for
management, for diplomacy, for rhetoric, and are certain
on occasions to arouse both the interest and the passions
of the Irish people. We may take it for granted
that the character of the Irish representation at
Westminster will govern the character of the Parliament
at Dublin.[39] Hence arises a third and fatal obstacle
to the active participation in Irish public life of
Irishmen who are not professional politicians.
The Home Rule Bill of 1893 professes to restrain on
every side the action of the Irish government and
Parliament. These Restrictions are the comfort
of English Gladstonians; they are thought to be safeguards,
though in reality there is nothing which they make
safe. But Restrictions which delight Gladstonians
are hateful to Irish Home Rulers. Their watchword
is, ‘Ireland a nation.’ To this cry
every Home Ruler will rally, and so too will, if once
the Union is broken up, many an ardent loyalist, converted
by anger at England’s treachery into an extreme
Nationalist. Irishmen will wish for an Irish
army; they will wish for a protective policy; they
will desire that Ireland shall play a part in foreign
affairs, and will claim for her at least the independence
of such a colony as New Zealand. To all these
wishes, and to many more, some of which under a system
of Home Rule are quite reasonable, the terms of the
Home Rule Bill are opposed. Home Rulers, and
probably enough the whole Irish people, will insist
that the Bill, which will then have become an Act,
must be modified. How is the modification to
be obtained? How is Home Rule to be made a reality?
By one method only: that is, by the freest use
of those arts Of intrigue and obstruction by which
Home Rule will have been gained. But for the
carrying out of such a policy the agitators and intriguers
who for the last twenty years have weakened and degraded
the Imperial Parliament are the proper agents.
For this work they, and they alone, are fit.
The quiet, industrious, stay-at-home merchants or lawyers,
who might be sent to Dublin for a month or two in
the year to manage Irish business on business-like
principles, will not be sent to Westminster to hold
the balance between English parties. They cannot