among a people like the Irish Roman Catholics.
Great discussion has taken place as to the countries
in which this Decree is in force. No one was surprised
to hear that Germany was exempt. Archbishop Walsh,
the Roman Catholic Archbishop of Dublin, in an elaborate
discussion, gives the opinion that the Decree is abrogated
under British law by the custom of the country, which
has in the past rendered impossible the observance
of the strict ecclesiastical rule in this matter,
but is careful to add that this is only his opinion
as a canonist, and is subject to the decision of the
Holy See. When this plea is examined, it is found
to mean simply this, that the law is not strictly
observed in case of necessity. That this is the
meaning of Archbishop Walsh’s plea is proved
by a quotation which he makes from Pope Benedict XIV.
The principle laid down by Pope Benedict is that when
it became impossible to resist the encroachment of
adverse customs, the Popes shut their eyes to what
was going on, and tolerated what they had no power
to prevent. It is exactly the principle of toleration
as a temporary expedient. The re-enactment of
the law by the present Pope means surely, if it means
anything, that such toleration is to cease wherever
and whenever the law can be enforced. But, be
it observed, this necessity is entirely dependent
on the strength of the authority which administers
the civil law. The moment the civil authority
grows weak in its assertion of its supremacy, the plea
of necessity fails, and the ecclesiastical law must
be enforced. Those who know Ireland are well
aware that this is exactly what would happen under
Home Rule. Here is the crowning proof of the truth
that, above all the well-intentioned persons who give
assurances of the peace and goodwill that would flourish
under Home Rule, there is a power which would bring
all their good intentions to nothing.
But what of the Church of Ireland under Home Rule?
Formerly the Established Church of the country, and
as such occupying a position of special privilege,
she still enjoys something of the traditional consideration
which belonged to that position, and is more than ever
conscious of her unbroken ecclesiastical descent from
the Ancient Church of Ireland. Her adherents
number 575,000, of whom 366,000 are in Ulster.
As part of her heritage she holds nearly all the ancient
ecclesiastical sites and the more important of the
ancient buildings which still survive. These
possessions, thus inherited from an immemorial past,
were secured to her by the Act of Disestablishment.
For the rest, the endowments which she enjoys at the
present time have been created since 1870 by the self-denial
and generosity of her clergy and laity. Under
British law, her position is secure. But would
she be secure under Home Rule? Those of her advisers
who have most right to speak with authority are convinced
that she would not. The Bishop of Ossory, in an
able and very moderate statement made at the meeting