of the victorious faction. But the Consiglio del
Comune, with the Podesta, who has not ceased to exercise
judicial functions, still subsists. The Priors
form the signory as of old. The Credenza goes
on working, and the Gran Consiglio represents the
body of privileged burghers. The party does but
tyrannize over the city it has conquered, and manipulates
the ancient constitution for its own advantage.
In this clash of Guelf with Ghibelline the beneficiaries
were the lower classes of the people. Excluded
from the Popolo of episcopal and consular revolutions,
the trades and industries of the great cities now assert
their claims to be enfranchised. The advent of
the Arti is the chief social phenomenon of
the crisis.[1] Thus the final issue of the conflict
was a new Italy, deeply divided by factions that were
little understood, because they were so vital, because
they represented two adverse currents of national
energy, incompatible, irreconcilable, eternal in antagonism
as the poles. But this discordant nation was more
commercial and more democratic. Families of merchants
rose upon the ruins of the old nobility. Roman
cities of industry reduced their military rivals of
earlier or later origin to insignificance. The
plain, the river, and the port asserted themselves
against the mountain fastness and the barrackburgh.
The several classes of society, triturated, shaken
together, leveled by warfare and equalized by industry,
presented but few obstacles to the emergence of commanding
personalities, however humble, from their ranks.
Not only had the hierarchy of feudalism disappeared;
but the constitution of the city itself was confused,
and the Popolo, whether ‘primo’ or ’secondo
or even ‘terzo,’ was diluted with recently
franchised Contadini and all kinds of ’novi homines.’[2]
The Divine Comedy, written after the culmination of
the Guelf and Ghibelline dissensions, yields the measure
of their animosity. Dante finds no place in Hell
Heaven, or Purgatory for the souls who stood aloof
from strife, the angels who were neither Guelf nor
Ghibelline in Paradise. His Vigliacchi, ‘wretches
who never lived,’ because they never felt the
pangs or ecstasies of partisanship, wander homeless
on the skirts of Limbo, among the abortions and offscourings
of creation. Even so there was no standing-ground
in Italy outside one or the other hostile camp.
Society was riven down to its foundation. Rancors
dating from the thirteenth century endured long after
the great parties ceased to have a meaning. They
were perpetuated in customs, and expressed themselves
in the most trivial details. Banners, ensigns,
and heraldic colors followed the divisions of the
factions. Ghibellines wore the feathers in their
caps upon one side, Guelfs upon the other. Ghibellines
cut fruit at table crosswise, Guelfs straight down.
In Bergamo some Calabrians were murdered by their
host, who discovered from their way of slicing garlic
that they sided with the hostile party. Ghibellines