principles. The struggle is a social struggle,
played out within the precincts of the Commune, for
the supremacy of one or the other moiety of the whole
people. A city does not pronounce itself either
Guelf or Ghibelline till half the burghers have been
exiled. The victorious party organizes the government
in its own interest, establishes itself in a Palazzo
apart from the Commune, where it develops its machinery
at home and abroad, and strengthens its finance by
forced contributions and confiscations.[1] The exiles
make common cause with members of their own faction
in an adverse burgh; and thus, by the diplomacy of
Guelfs and Ghibellines, the most distant centers are
drawn into the network of a common dualism. In
this way we are justified in saying that Italy achieved
her national consciousness through strife and conflict;
for the Communes ceased to be isolated, cemented by
temporary leagues, or engaged in merely local conflicts.
They were brought together and connected by the sympathies
and antipathies of an antagonism which embraced and
dominated the municipalities, set Republics and Regno
on equal footing, and merged the titular leaders of
the struggle, Pope and Emperor, in the uncontrollable
tumult. The issue was no vulgar one; no merely
egotistic interests were at stake. Guelfs and
Ghibellines alike interrogated the oracle, with perfect
will to obey its inspiration for the common good;
but they read the utterances of the Pythia in adverse
senses. The Ghibelline heard Italy calling upon
him to build a citadel that should be guarded by the
lance and shield of chivalry, where the hierarchies
of feudalism, ranged beneath the dais of the Empire,
might dispense culture and civil order in due measure
to the people. The Guelf believed that she was
bidding him to multiply arts and guilds within the
burgh, beneath the mantle of the Pope, who stood for
Christ, the preacher of equality and peace for all
mankind, in order that the beehive of industry should
in course of time evolve a civil order and a culture
representative of its own freely acting forces.
[1] It is enough to refer
to the importance of the Parte Guelfa in
the history of Florence.
During the stress and storm of the fierce warfare
carried on by Guelfs and Ghibellines, the Podesta
fell into the second rank. He had been created
to meet an emergency; but now the discord was too vehement
for arbitration. A new functionary appears, with
the title of Captain of the People. Chosen
when one or other of the factions gains supreme power
in the burgh, he represents the victorious party, takes
the lead in proscribing their opponents, and ratifies
on his responsibility the changes introduced into
the constitution. The old magistracies and councils,
meanwhile, are not abrogated. The Consiglio del
Popolo, with the Capitano at its head, takes the lead;
and a new member, called the Consiglio della Parte,
is found beside them, watchful to maintain the policy