position assumed by the friar in his war with Rome
was not a strong one, and the reasoning by which he
supported it was marked by curious self-deception
mingled with apparent efforts to deceive his audience.
He had not the audacious originality of Luther.
He never went to the length of braving Alexander by
burning his bulls and by denying the authority of
popes in general. Not daring to break all connection
with the Holy See, he was driven to quibble about
the distinction between the office and the man, assuming
a hazardous attitude of obedience to the Church whose
head and chief he daily outraged. At the same
time he took no pains to enlist the sympathies of
the Italian princes, many of whom might presumably
have been hostile to the Pope, on his side of the
quarrel. All the tyrants came in for a share of
his prophetic indignation. Lodovico Sforza, the
lord of Mirandola, and Piero de’ Medici felt
themselves specially aggrieved, and kept urging Alexander
to extinguish this source of scandal to established
governments. Against so great and powerful a
host one man could not stand alone. Savonarola’s
position became daily more dangerous in Florence.
The merchants, excommunicated by the Pope and thus
exposed to pillage in foreign markets, grumbled at
the friar who spoiled their trade. The ban of
interdiction lay upon the city, where the sacraments
could no longer be administered or the dead be buried
with the rites of Christians. Meanwhile a band
of high-spirited and profligate young men, called
Compagnacci, used every occasion to insult and interrupt
him. At last in March 1498 his staunch friends,
the Signory, or supreme executive of Florence, suspended
him from preaching in the Duomo. Even the populace
were weary of the protracted quarrel with the Holy
See: nor could any but his own fanatical adherents
anticipate the wars which threatened the state, with
equanimity.
Savonarola himself felt that the supreme hour was
come. One more resource was left; to that he
would now betake himself: he could afterwards
but die. This last step was the convening of a
general council.[1] Accordingly he addressed letters
to all the European potentates. One of these,
inscribed to Charles VIII., was dispatched, intercepted,
and conveyed to Alexander. He wrote also to the
Pope and warned him of his purpose. The termination
of that epistle is noteworthy: ’I can thus
have no longer any hope in your Holiness, but must
turn to Christ alone, who chooses the weak of this
world to confound the strong lions among the perverse
generations. He will assist me to prove and sustain,
in the face of the world, the holiness of the work
for the sake of which I so greatly suffer: and
He will inflict a just punishment on those who persecute
me and would impede its progress. As for myself,
I seek no earthly glory, but long eagerly for death.
May your Holiness no longer delay but look to your
salvation.’