at one another across the Valdichiana, Perugia rears
a tower against Chiusi, and Chiusi builds her Becca
Questa in responsive menace. The tiniest burgh
upon the Arno receives from Dante, the poet of this
internecine strife and fierce town-rivalry, its stigma
of immortalizing satire and insulting epithet, for
no apparent reason but that its dwellers dare to drink
of the same water and to breathe the same air as Florence.
It would seem as though the most ancient furies of
antagonistic races, enchained and suspended for centuries
by the magic of Rome, had been unloosed; as though
the indigenous populations of Italy, tamed by antique
culture, were reverting to their primal instincts,
with all the discords and divisions introduced by
the military system of the Lombards, the feudalism
of the Franks, the alien institutions of the Germans,
superadded to exasperate the passions of a nation
blindly struggling against obstacles that block the
channel of continuous progress. Nor is this the
end of the perplexity. Not only are the cities
at war with one another, but they are plunged in ceaseless
strife within the circuit of their ramparts.
The people with the nobles, the burghs with the castles,
the plebeians with the burgher aristocracy, the men
of commerce with the men of arms and ancient lineage,
Guelfs and Ghibellines, clash together in persistent
fury. One half the city expels the other half.
The exiles roam abroad, cement alliances, and return
to extirpate their conquerors. Fresh proscriptions
and new expulsions follow. Again alliances are
made and revolutions accomplished, till the ancient
feuds of the towns are crossed, recrossed, and tangled
in a web of madness that defies analysis. Through
the medley of quarreling, divided, subdivided, and
intertwisted factions, ride Emperors followed by their
bands of knights, appearing for a season on vain quests,
and withdrawing after they have tenfold confounded
the confusion. Papal Legates drown the cities
of the Church in blood, preach crusades, fulminate
interdictions, rouse insurrections in the States that
own allegiance to the Empire. Monks stir republican
revivals in old cities that have lost their liberties,
or assemble the populations of crime-maddened districts
in aimless comedies of piety and false pacification,
or lead them barefooted and intoxicated with shrill
cries of ‘Mercy’ over plain and mountain.
Princes of France, Kings of Bohemia and Hungary, march
and countermarch from north to south and back again,
form leagues, establish realms, head confederations,
which melt like shapes we form from clouds to nothing.
At one time the Pope and Emperor use Italy as the arena
of a deadly duel, drawing the congregated forces of
the nation into their dispute. At another they
join hands to divide the spoil of ruined provinces.
Great generals with armies at their backs start into
being from apparent nothingness, dispute the sovereignty
of Italy in bloodless battles, found ephemeral dynasties,
and pass away like mists upon a mountain-side beneath
a puff of wind. Conflict, ruin, desolation, anarchy
are ever yielding place to concord, restoration, peace,
prosperity, and then recurring with a mighty flood
of violence. Construction, destruction, and reconstruction
play their part in crises that have to be counted by
the thousands.