What is the stagecraft of Scribe compared with this?
how else could the avowal of love be brought about
with such instant and stupendous effect? Quite
as amazing is the second act. Almost from the
beginning to close on the end the lovers fondle each
other, in a garden before an old castle in the sultry
summer night; and just as their passion reaches its
highest pitch, Mark breaks in upon them. For
Tristan, at least, death is imminent; and the mere
presence of death serves to begin the change from the
desire of the flesh to the ecstatic spiritual passion.
That change is completed in the next act, where we
have the scene laid before Tristan’s deserted
and dilapidated castle in Brittany, with the calm sea
in the distance (it should shine like burnished steel);
and here Tristan lies dying of the wound he received
from Melot in the previous scene, while a melody from
the shepherd’s pipe, the saddest melody ever
heard, floats melancholy and wearily through the hot,
close, breathless air. Kurvenal, his servant,
has sent for Isolda to cure him as she had cured him
before; and when at last she comes Tristan grows crazy
with joy, tears the bandages from his wounds, and
dies just as she enters. This finishes the metamorphosis
begun in the second act: after some other incidents,
Isolda, rapt in her spiritual love, sings the death-song
and dies over Tristan’s body. What is the
libretto of “Otello” or of “Falstaff”
compared with this libretto? From beginning to
end there is not a line, not an incident, in excess.
Anyone who is wearied by King Mark’s long address
when he comes on the guilty pair, has failed to catch
the drift of the whole opera—failed to see
that two souls like Tristan and Isolda, wholly swayed
by love, must find Mark’s grief wholly unintelligible,
and have no power of explaining themselves to those
not possessed with a passion like theirs, or of bringing
themselves into touch with the workaday world of daylight,
and that all Mark’s most moving appeal means
to them is that this world, where such annoyances
occur, is not the land in which they fain would dwell.
They live wholly for their illusion, and if it is
forbidden to them in life they will seek death; nothing—not
honour, shame, the affection of Mark, the faithfulness
of Kurvenal, least of all, life—is to be
considered in comparison with their love; their love
is the love that is all in all. It is entirely
selfish: Mark is as much their enemy as Melot,
his affection more to be dreaded than the sword of
Melot.
Perhaps I have given the drama some of the credit that should go to the music; and at least there is not a dramatic situation which the music does not immeasurably increase in power. But indeed the two are inseparable. The music creates the mood and holds the spectator to it so that the true significance of the dramatic situation cannot fail to be felt; while the dramatic situation makes the highest, most extravagant flights of the music quite intelligible,