create “Tristan.” And in “Tristan”
we commence with a fleshly love, as intense as that
Tannhaeuser knew; but by reason of its own energy,
its own excess, it rises to a spiritual love as free
from grossness as any dreamed of by Elizabeth or Wolfram,
and far surpassing theirs in exaltation. This
change he depicted in a way as simple as it was marvellous,
so that as we watch the drama and listen to the music
we experience it within ourselves and our inner selves
are revealed to us. Nothing comes between us and
the passions expressed. Tristan and Isolda are
passion in its purest integrity, naked souls vibrating
with the keenest emotion; they have no idiosyncrasies
to be sympathised with, to be allowed for; they are
generalisations, not characters, and in them we see
only ourselves reflected on the stage—ourselves
as we are under the spell of Wagner’s music
and of his drama. For “Tristan” seems
to me the most wonderful of Wagner’s dramas,
far more wonderful than “Parsifal,” far
more wonderful than “Tannhaeuser.”
There is no stroke in it that is not inevitable, none
that does not immensely and immediately tell; and,
despite its literary quality, one fancies it could
not fail to make some measure of its effect were it
played without the music. Think of the first
act. The scene is the deck of the ship; the wind
is fresh, and charged with the bitterness of the salt
sea; and Isolda sits there consumed with burning anger
and hate of the man she loves, whose life she spared
because she loved him, and who now rewards her by
carrying her off, almost as the spoil of war, to be
the wife of his king. It has been said that Tolstoi
asserted for the first time in “The Kreuzer
Sonata” that hate and love were the same passion.
But the truth is, Wagner knew it long before Tolstoi,
just as Shakespeare knew it long before Wagner; and
the whole of this first act turns on it. Isolda
sends for Tristan and tells him he has wronged her,
and begs him to drink the cup of peace with her.
Tristan sees precisely what she means, and, loving
her, drinks the proffered poison as an atonement for
the wrong he has done her, and for his treachery to
himself in winning her, for ambition’s sake,
as King Mark’s bride instead of taking her as
his own. But the moment her hatred is satisfied
Isolda finds life intolerable without it, without love;
her love a second time betrays her; and she seizes
the poison and drinks also. Then comes the masterstroke.
Done with this world, with nothing but death before
them, the two confess their long-pent love; in their
exalted state passion comes over them like a flood;
in the first rush of passion, honour, shame, friendship
seem mere names of illusions, and love is the only
real thing in life; and finally, the death draught
being no death draught, but a slight infusion of cantharides,
the two passionately cling to each other, vaguely wondering
what all the noise is about, while the ship reaches
land and all the people shout and the trumpets blow.