a little passe now. Is it indeed so?
Well, Mozart lived in the last days of the old world,
and the old world and the thoughts and sentiments
of the old world are certainly a little passes
now. But if you examine “Don Giovanni”
you must admit that the Fifth and Ninth symphonies,
“Fidelio,” “Lohengrin,” the
“Ring,” “Tristan,” and “Parsifal”
have done nothing to eclipse its glories, that while
fresh masterpieces have come forth, “Don Giovanni”
remains a masterpiece amongst masterpieces, that in
a sense it is a masterpiece towards which all other
masterpieces stand in the relation of commentaries
to text. And though this, perhaps, is only to
call it a link in a chain, yet it is curious to note
how very closely other composers have followed Mozart,
and how greatly they are indebted to him. Page
upon page of the early Beethoven is written in the
phraseology of the later Mozart; in nearly every bar
of “Faust,” not to mention “Romeo
and Juliette,” avowedly the fruit of a long study
of “Don Giovanni,” a faint echo of Mozart’s
voice comes to us with the voice of Gounod; Anna’s
cries, “Quel sangue, quella piaga, quel volto,”
with the creeping chromatic chords of the wood-wind,
have the very accent of Isolda’s ’"Tis
I, belov’d,” and the solemn phrase that
follows, in Tristan’s death-scene. Apart
from its influence on later composers, there is surely
no more passionate, powerful, and moving drama in
the world than “Don Giovanni.” Despite
the triviality of Da Ponte’s book, the impetus
of the music carries along the action at a tremendous
speed; the moments of relief occur just when relief
is necessary, and never retard the motion; the climaxes
are piled up with incredible strength and mastery,
and have an emotional effect as powerful as anything
in “Fidelio” and equal to anything in Wagner’s
music-dramas; and most stupendous of all is the finale,
with its tragic blending of the grotesque and the
terrible. Or, if one considers detail, in no
other opera do the characters depict themselves in
every phrase they utter as they do in “Don Giovanni.”
The songs stamp Mozart as the greatest song-writer
who has lived, with the exception of Handel, whose
opera songs are immeasurably beyond all others save
Mozart’s, and a little beyond them. The
mere musicianship is as consummate as Bach’s,
for, like Bach, Mozart possessed that facility which
is fatal to many men, but combined with it a high
sincerity, a greedy thirst for the beautiful, and an
emotional force that prevented it being fatal to him.
For delicacy, subtlety, due brilliancy, and strength,
the orchestral colouring cannot be matched. And
no music is more exclusively its own composer’s,
has less in it of other composers’. Beethoven
is Beethoven plus Mozart, Wagner is Wagner
plus Weber and Beethoven; but from every page
of Mozart’s scores Mozart alone looks at you,
with sad laughter in his eyes, and unspeakable tenderness,
the tenderness of the giants, of Handel, Bach, and
Beethoven, though perhaps Mozart is tenderest of them