that the manufacturers and traders have joined hands
to advance a movement beneficial to themselves; the
best thought of every class in the country has given
enthusiastic support to the programme on grounds not
of personal interest but of national duty. We
may therefore take it that the watchword of the Second
Empire,
Enrichissez-vous, will be the watchword
of a self-governing Ireland. What Parliament and
the State can do to forward that aim will naturally
be a subject of controversy. To Free Traders
and Tariff Reformers, alike, the power that controls
the Customs’ tariff of a country controls its
economic destiny. Both would seem bound to apply
the logic of their respective gospels to Ireland.
But as it is not the aim of this book to anticipate
the debates of next year, but rather to explain the
foundations of the Home Rule idea, we may leave that
burning question for the present untouched. Apart
from it we can anticipate the trend of policy in Ireland.
The first great task of a Home Rule Parliament would
be above controversy; it would be neither more nor
less than a scientific exploration of the country.
No such Economic Survey has ever been made, and the
results are lamentable. There has been no mapping
out of the soil areas from the point of view of Agricultural
Economics, and, for the lack of such impartial information,
the fundamental conflict between tillage and grazing
goes on in the dark. We know where coal is to
be found in Ireland; we do not know with any assurance
where it is and where it is not profitably workable.
The same is true of granite, marble, and indeed all
our mineral resources.
The woollen industry flourishes in one district and
fails in another, to all appearance as favourably
situated; it seems capable of great expansion and
yet it does not expand greatly. What then are
the conditions of success? Here is a typical
case that calls for scientific analysis. One
can pick at random a dozen such instances. Ireland,
admirably adapted to the production of meat, does not
produce meat, but only the raw material of it, store
cattle. Is this state of things immutable?
Or is a remedy for it to be found, say, in a redistribution
of the incidence of local taxation so as to favour
well-used land as against ill-used land? Is the
decline in the area under flax to be applauded or
deplored? Can Irish-grown wool be improved up
to the fineness of the Australian article? And
so on, and so on. It is to be noted that of the
statistics which we do possess many of the most important
are, to say the least, involved in doubt. The
Export and Import figures are little better than volunteer
estimates; there is no compulsion to accuracy.
As to the yield of crops, all that can be said is
that our present information is not as bad as it used
to be. But above all we have no comprehensive
notion of the condition of the people. Whenever
there has been an inquiry into wages, cost of living,
or any other fundamental fact, Ireland has come in