Confucius not a God

It should be noted that Confucius himself is not a god, though he has been and is worshipped (66,000 animals used to be offered to him every year; probably the number is about the same now).  Suggestions have been made to make him the God of China and Confucianism the religion of China, so that he and his religion would hold the same relative positions that Christ and Christianity do in the West.  I was present at the lengthy debate which took place on this subject in the Chinese Parliament in February 1917, but in spite of many long, learned, and eloquent speeches, chiefly by scholars of the old school, the motion was not carried.  Nevertheless, the worship accorded to Confucius was and is (except by ‘new’ or ‘young’ China) of so extreme a nature that he may almost be described as the great unapotheosized god of China. [14] Some of his portraits even ascribe to him superhuman attributes.  But in spite of all this the fact remains that Confucius has not been appointed a god and holds no exequatur entitling him to that rank.

If we inquire into the reason of this we find that, astonishing though it may seem, Confucius is classed by the Chinese not as a god (shen), but as a demon (kuei).  A short historical statement will make the matter clear.

In the classical Li chi, Book of Ceremonial, we find the categorical assignment of the worship of certain objects to certain subjective beings:  the emperor worshipped Heaven and earth, the feudal princes the mountains and rivers, the officials the hearth, and the literati their ancestors.  Heaven, earth, mountains, rivers, and hearth were called shen (gods), and ancestors kuei (demons).  This distinction is due to Heaven being regarded as the god and the people as demons—­the upper is the god, the lower the evil spirit or demon.  Though kuei were usually bad, the term in Chinese includes both good and evil spirits.  In ancient times those who had by their meritorious virtue while in the world averted calamities from the people were posthumously worshipped and called gods, but those who were worshipped by their descendants only were called spirits or demons.

In the worship of Confucius by emperors of various dynasties (details of which need not be given here) the highest titles conferred on him were Hsien Sheng, ‘Former or Ancestral Saint,’ and even Win Hsuean Wang, ‘Accomplished and Illustrious Prince,’ and others containing like epithets.  When for his image or idol there was (in the eleventh year—­A.D. 1307—­of the reign-period Ta Te of the Emperor Ch’eng Tsung of the Yuean dynasty) substituted the tablet now seen in the Confucian temples, these were the inscriptions engraved on it.  In the inscriptions authoritatively placed on the tablets the word shen does not occur; in those cases where it does occur it has been placed there (as by the Taoists) illegally and without authority by too ardent devotees.  Confucius may not be called a shen, since there is no record showing that the great ethical teacher was ever apotheosized, or that any order was given that the character shen was to be applied to him.