Outspoken Essays eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 361 pages of information about Outspoken Essays.

Outspoken Essays eBook

This eBook from the Gutenberg Project consists of approximately 361 pages of information about Outspoken Essays.
the autocrat becomes the most unscrupulous of demagogues, and stirs up racial or religious or social hatred, or the lust for foreign war, with less scruple than a newspaper proprietor under a democracy,’ The autocrat, in fact, is often a slave, as the demagogue is often a tyrant.  Lastly, the democrat may urge that one of the commonest accusations against democracy—­that the populace chooses its rulers badly—­is not true in times of great national danger.  On the contrary, it often shows a sound instinct in finding the strongest man to carry it through a crisis.  At such times the parrots and monkeys are discarded, and a Napoleon or a Kitchener is given a free hand, though he may have despised all the demagogic arts.  In other words, a democracy sometimes knows when to abdicate.  The excesses of revolutionists are not an argument against democracy, since revolutions are anything rather than democratic.

Nevertheless, the indictment against democracy is a very heavy one, and it is worth while to state the main items in the charge.

1.  Whatever may be truly said about the good sense of a democracy during a great crisis, at ordinary times it does not bring the best men to the top.  Professor Hearnshaw, in his admirable ’Democracy at the Crossroads,’ collects a number of weighty opinions confirming this judgment.  Carlyle, who proclaimed the merits of silence in some thirty volumes, blames democracy for ignoring the ‘noble, silent men’ who could serve it best, and placing power in the hands of windbags.  Ruskin, Matthew Arnold, Sir James Stephen, Sir Henry Maine, and Lecky, all agree that ’the people have for the most part neither the will nor the power to find out the best men to lead them.’  In France the denunciations of democratic politicians are so general that it would be tedious to enumerate the writers who have uttered them.  One example will suffice; the words are the words of Anatole Beaulieu in 1885: 

The wider the circle from which politicians and state-functionaries are recruited, the lower seems their intellectual level to have sunk.  This deterioration in the personnel of government has been yet more striking from the moral point of view.  Politics have tended to become more corrupt, more debased, and to soil the hands of those who take part in them and the men who get their living by them.  Political battles have become too bitter and too vulgar not to have inspired aversion in the noblest and most upright natures by their violence and their intrigues.  The elite of the nation in more than one country are showing a tendency to have nothing to do with them.  Politics is an industry in which a man, to prosper, requires less intelligence and knowledge than boldness and capacity for intrigue.  It has already become in some states the most ignominious of careers.  Parties are syndicates for exploitation, and its forms become ever more shameless.

A later account of French politics, drawn from inside

Copyrights
Project Gutenberg
Outspoken Essays from Project Gutenberg. Public domain.