that of a good, conscientious, but illiterate Scotch
Presbyterian Border farmer of a century or two back,
having perfect faith in the bodily appearances of
Satan and his imps; and in all kelpies, brownies, and
fairies. Substitute for the indignant terrors
in this man’s mind, a general persuasion of
the Divinity, more or less beneficent, yet
faultful, of all these beings; that is to say, take
away his belief in the demoniacal malignity of the
fallen spiritual world, and lower, in the same degree,
his conceptions of the angelical, retaining for him
the same firm faith in both; keep his ideas about flowers
and beautiful scenery much as they are,—his
delight in regular ploughed land and meadows, and
a neat garden (only with rows of gooseberry bushes
instead of vines), being, in all probability, about
accurately representative of the feelings of Ulysses;
then, let the military spirit that is in him, glowing
against the Border forager, or the foe of old Flodden
and Chevy-Chase,[110] be made more principal, with
a higher sense of nobleness in soldiership, not as
a careless excitement, but a knightly duty; and increased
by high cultivation of every personal quality, not
of mere shaggy strength, but graceful strength, aided
by a softer climate, and educated in all proper harmony
of sight and sound: finally, instead of an informed
Christian, suppose him to have only the patriarchal
Jewish knowledge of the Deity, and even this obscured
by tradition, but still thoroughly solemn and faithful,
requiring his continual service as a priest of burnt
sacrifice and meat offering; and I think we shall get
a pretty close approximation to the vital being of
a true old Greek; some slight difference still existing
in a feeling which the Scotch farmer would have of
a pleasantness in blue hills and running streams, wholly
wanting in the Greek mind; and perhaps also some difference
of views on the subjects of truth and honesty.
But the main points, the easy, athletic, strongly
logical and argumentative, yet fanciful and credulous,
characters of mind, would be very similar in both;
and the most serious change in the substance of the
stuff among the modifications above suggested as necessary
to turn the Scot into the Greek, is that effect of
softer climate and surrounding luxury, inducing the
practice of various forms of polished art,—the
more polished, because the practical and realistic
tendency of the Hellenic mind (if my interpretation
of it be right) would quite prevent it from taking
pleasure in any irregularities of form, or imitations
of the weeds and wildnesses of that mountain nature
with which it thought itself born to contend.
In its utmost refinement of work, it sought eminently
for orderliness; carried the principle of the leeks
in squares, and fountains in pipes, perfectly out
in its streets and temples; formalized whatever decoration
it put into its minor architectural mouldings, and
reserved its whole heart and power to represent the
action of living men, or gods, though not unconscious,
meanwhile, of