For now, in a flash, he saw and understood beyond the limits to which the girl’s vision had gone, grasping explanations denied to her.  She had told him everything which she knew or suspected, saying somewhere in her account, “I know now that my first judgment of you, before I was deceived into thinking Ben Broderick you, was right.  I know that you are a man and a gentleman.  I know that you are ‘square.’  So now, if you think that you owe me anything for what I am doing for you, I want you to remember that Henry Pollard is my uncle, my dead mother’s brother, and to make things no harder for him than he has made them for himself.”

With no other reference to her relation to the man, with no further hint of a plea for herself, she went on to tell what she knew of Pollard and Broderick, of their meetings with Dalton whom, she thought, they had completely deceived, of the talk she had overheard that night at the schoolhouse.  She said nothing of her own precarious position at Pollard’s house.  When he finished reading Buck Thornton’s eyes were very bright.

“A real woman,” he muttered.  “A real man’s sort of girl!  I doped her up right at the first jump, and then I went and insulted her by thinking that she was like ‘Rattlesnake’ Pollard!  Lord, Lordy!  What a difference!” And then, very gently, his eyes clouding a little, he muttered over and over, under his breath:  “Poor little kid!”

But ever his thoughts came back to the tangle into which day by day he himself had been moving deeper and deeper.  He saw how simple the whole matter had been, how seemingly sure of success.  Broderick was close enough to him in size and form to make the scheme eminently practicable.  It was easy for Broderick to dress himself as Thornton dressed, boots, chaps old and worn, big black hat and grey neck handkerchief.  It was simple enough for Broderick, here in this land of cattle and horses, to find a horse that would be a fair match for any horse which Thornton rode.  He would allow himself to be seen only at a distance, as upon the day Winifred Waverly had seen him, or indistinctly at night, and when the time came and the arrest was made there would rise up many men to swear to Buck Thornton....  Broderick himself had already said that he had been robbed of a can of gold dust.  He would be ready to swear that Thornton had robbed him.  Pollard would add his word....

One by one he remembered episodes which until now had meant nothing.  Cattle had been stolen from the ranges all about him; no single cow was missing from the Poison Hole.  He had thought that this had been because of his own great vigilance, his night-riding over his herds.  But what would a jury say?  He remembered that the last time he had seen old man King, just a few days ago, when King had remarked drily upon the fact that no cattle were missing from Thornton’s range, there had been a swift look of suspicion in the old cattle man’s shrewd eyes.  Already he was suspected.  How many men besides King were ready to believe the worst of Buck Thornton, a man who had been in their midst only a year?