for every preacher has not the musical voice of Chrysostom,
or the electricity of St. Bernard. He can neither
draw nor inspire if he cannot be heard; he speaks to
stones, not to living men or women. He loses
his power, and is driven to chants and music to keep
his audience from deserting him. He must make
his choir an orchestra; he must hide himself in priestly
vestments; he must import opera singers to amuse and
not instruct. He cannot instruct when he cannot
be heard, and heard easily. Unless the people
catch every tone of his voice his electricity will
be wasted, and he will preach in vain, and be tired
out by attempting to prevent echoes. The voice
of Saint Paul would be lost in some of our modern
fashionable churches. Think of the absurdity
of Baptists and Methodists and Presbyterians affecting
to restore Gothic monuments, when the great end of
sacred eloquence is lost in those devices which appeal
to sense. Think of the folly of erecting a church
for eight hundred people as high as Westminster Abbey.
It is not the size of a church which prevents the
speaker from being heard,—it is the disproportion
of height with breadth and length, and the echoes
produced by arcades, Spurgeon is heard easily by seven
thousand people, and Talmage by six thousand, and
Dr. Hall by four thousand, because the buildings in
which they preach are adapted to public speaking.
Those who erect theatres take care that a great crowd
shall be able to catch even the whispers of actors.
What would you think of the good sense and judgment
of an architect who should construct a reservoir that
would leak, in order to make it ornamental; or a schoolhouse
without ventilation; or a theatre where actors could
only be seen; or a hotel without light and convenient
rooms; or a railroad bridge which would not support
a heavy weight?
A Protestant church is designed, no matter what the
sect may be to which it belongs, not for poetical
or aesthetic purposes, not for the admiration of architectural
expenditures, not even for music, but for earnest
people to hear from the preacher the words of life
and death, that they may be aroused by his enthusiasm,
or instructed by his wisdom; where the poor are not
driven to a few back seats in the gallery; where the
meeting is cheerful and refreshing, where all are
stimulated to duties. It must not be dark, damp,
and gloomy, where it is necessary to light the gas
on a foggy day, and where one must be within ten feet
of the preacher to see the play of his features.
Take away facilities for hearing and even for seeing
the preacher, and the vitality of a Protestant service
is destroyed, and the end for which the people assemble
is utterly defeated. Moreover, you destroy the
sacred purposes of a church if you make it so expensive
that the poor cannot get sittings. Nothing is
so dull, depressing, funereal, as a church occupied
only by prosperous pew-holders, who come together to
show their faces and prove their respectability, rather