Kittie said yes, but they had come to ask him to take them skating, and they were all ready and had brought their skates.  His face fell, as real writers say, and he hesitated a little, but at last he said he’d go, and he excused himself, just as if they had been grown up, and went off to get ready.

When they were left alone a terrible doubt assailed Mabel, and she asked Kittie if she was going to ask George again to marry her.  Kittie blushed and said she was not, of course, and that she knew better now.  For it is indeed true that the human heart is not so easily turned from its dear object.  We know that if once one truly loves it lasts forever and ever and ever, and then one dies and is buried with things the loved one wore.

Kittie said she had a plan to help George, and all Mabel had to do was to watch and keep on breathing.  Mabel felt better then, and said she guessed she could do that.  George came back all ready, and they started off.  Kittie acted rather dark and mysterious, but Mabel conversed with George in the easy and pleasant fashion young men love.  She told him all about school and how bad she was in mathematics; and he said he had been a duffer at it too, but that he had learned to shun it while there was yet time.  And he advised her very earnestly to have nothing to do with it.  Mabel didn’t, either, after she came back to St. Catharine’s; and when Sister Irmingarde reproached her, Mabel said she was leaning on the judgment of a strong man, as woman should do.  But Sister Irmingarde made her go on with the arithmetic just the same.

By and by they came to the river, and it was so early not many people were skating there.  When George had fastened on their skates—­he did it in the nicest way, exactly as if they were grown up—­Kittie looked more mysterious than ever, and she started off as fast as she could skate toward a little inlet where there was no one at all.  George and Mabel followed her.  George said he didn’t know whether the ice was smooth in there, but Kittie kept right on, and George did not say any more.  I guess he did not care much where he went.  I suppose it disappoints a man when he wants to marry a woman and she won’t.  Now that I am beginning to study deeply this question of love, many things are clear to me.

Kittie kept far ahead, and all of a sudden Mabel saw that a little distance further on, and just ahead, there was a big black hole in the ice, and Kittie was skating straight toward it.  Mabel tried to scream, but she says the sound froze on her pallid lips.  Then George saw the hole, too, and rushed toward Kittie, and quicker than I can write it Kittie went in that hole and down.