“But,” said I, “let us contemplate a different issue.  Let us think what a result it will be if such a government as ours, whose speedy ruin has been so often predicted and is still confidently looked for, shall pass through these trials and dangers without bloodshed, and we become again a united people.  Self-government will then have vindicated itself; constitutional liberty will have triumphed; arms and coercion will lose their old authority and power; for there will be an example of a republican people recovering from convulsions which would have demolished any throne or power which trusted in the sword.  The serf-boats in ports of the Bay of Bengal, which ride the swift, enormous surges, are not nailed, but their parts are lashed one to another, and thus the boats yield easily to the force of the water.  Our government has been likened to them; and now, by yielding, one part to another, where a theoretically stronger government would have used coercion, we shall, if it please God, pass safely through these fearful hazards, furnishing a demonstration, which God may have been preparing by us for the instruction of mankind, that fraternal blood is not the best nourishment of the tree of liberty, and that ‘wisdom,’ resulting in the victories of peace, ‘is better than weapons of war.’

“I look, therefore, toward some change in Northern feelings with regard to the South.  A change in this respect will end our troubles.  Opinions may not be wholly reversed; people born and bred under totally different institutions may not, for they cannot wholly, yield their convictions on controverted sectional topics, even when they cherish mutual respect and deference; but, the belief that the North will change its feelings toward the South and its institutions, under a modification of views entirely consistent with independence of judgment and self-respect, and that the South will not be wanting in a corresponding temper, rests on the same conviction as that God does not intend to destroy us by each other’s hands, nor to make the life of the two sections weary with perpetual hatred and strife.”

* * * * *

“Our form of government, Mr. North,” said I, “is the very best on earth if it goes well, and the worst if it goes ill.  We have no standing army to fight for an administration as for a throne or dynasty; so that if a State secedes, the question is how to coerce that people, if it be best to attempt it.  Citizens do not like to march against their brethren.  Think of our taking up arms against our correspondents; against people that have gone from our churches and settled in that State; against cousins, and brothers-in-law, and people who lived or did business under the same roofs with us.”

“It is awkward, indeed,” said Mr. North, “especially if they simply withdraw and hold the fortifications of the general government, in their own territory, to keep the government from destroying their lives.”