simplicity and spirituality of the Platonists, invented
the word “Latitudinarian” to throw at
them, “a long nickname which they have taught
their tongues to pronounce as roundly as if it were
shorter than it is by four or five syllables”;
but they could not deny that their enemies were loyal
sons of the Church of England.[359] What the Platonists
meant by making reason the seat of authority may be
seen by a few quotations from Whichcote and Smith,
who for our purpose are, I think, the best representatives
of the school. Whichcote answers Tuckney, who
had remonstrated with him for “a vein of doctrine,
in which reason hath too much given to it in the mysteries
of faith";—“Too much” and “too
often” on these points! “The Scripture
is full of such truths, and I discourse on them too
much and too often! Sir, I oppose not rational
to spiritual, for spiritual is most rational.”
Elsewhere he writes, “He that gives reason for
what he has said, has done what is fit to be done,
and the most that can be done.” “Reason
is the Divine Governor of man’s life; it is
the very voice of God.” “When the
doctrine of the Gospel becomes the reason of our mind,
it will be the principle of our life.”
“It ill becomes us to make our intellectual
faculties Gibeonites.[360]” How far this teaching
differs from the frigid “common-sense”
morality prevalent in the eighteenth century, may
be judged from the following, which stamps Whichcote
as a genuine mystic. “Though liberty of
judgment be everyone’s right, yet how few there
are that make use of this right! For the use of
this right doth depend upon self-improvement by meditation,
consideration, examination, prayer, and the like.
These are things antecedent and prerequisite.”
John Smith, in a fine passage too long to quote in
full, says: “Reason in man being lumen
de lumine, a light flowing from the Fountain and
Father of lights ... was to enable man to work out
of himself all those notions of God which are the true
groundwork of love and obedience to God, and conformity
to Him.... But since man’s fall from God,
the inward virtue and vigour of reason is much abated,
the soul having suffered a [Greek: pterorryesis],
as Plato speaks, a defluvium pennarum....
And therefore, besides the truth of natural inscription,
God hath provided the truth of Divine revelation....
But besides this outward revelation, there is also
an inward impression of it ... which is in a more
special manner attributed to God.... God only
can so shine upon our glassy understandings, as to
beget in them a picture of Himself, and turn the soul
like wax or clay to the seal of His own light and love.
He that made our souls in His own image and likeness
can easily find a way into them. The Word that
God speaks, having found a way into the soul, imprints
itself there as with the point of a diamond....
It is God alone that acquaints the soul with the truths
of revelation, and also strengthens and raises the
soul to better apprehensions even of natural truth,
God being that in the intellectual world which the
sun is in the sensible, as some of the ancient Fathers
love to speak, and the ancient philosophers too, who
meant God by their Intellectus Agens[361] whose
proper work they supposed to be not so much to enlighten
the object as the faculty.”