and to feel itself socially rather English than Irish.
Thus the chasm between the immigrants and the aborigines
has grown deeper. The upper class has not that
Irish patriotism which it showed in the days of the
National Irish Parliament (1782-1800), and while there
is thus less of a common national feeling to draw
rich and poor together, the strife of landlords and
tenants has continued, irritating the minds of both
parties, and gathering them into two hostile camps.
As everybody knows, the Nationalist agitation has
been intimately associated with the Land agitation—has,
in fact, found a strong motive-force in the desire
of the tenants to have their rents reduced, and themselves
secured against eviction. Now, many people in
England assumed that an Irish Parliament would be
under the control of the tenants and the humbler class
generally, and would therefore be hostile to the landlords.
They went farther, and made the much bolder assumption
that as such a Parliament would be chosen by electors,
most of whom were Roman Catholics, it would be under
the control of the Catholic priesthood, and hostile
to Protestants. Thus they supposed that the grant
of self-government to Ireland would mean the abandonment
of the upper and wealthier class, the landlords and
the Protestants, to the tender mercies of their enemies.
Such abandonment, it was proclaimed on a thousand
platforms, would be disgraceful in itself, dishonouring
to England, a betrayal of the very men who had stood
by her in the past, and were prepared to stand by
her in the future, if only she would stand by them.
It was, of course, replied by the defenders of the
Home Rule Bill, that what the so-called English party
in Ireland really stood by was their own ascendency
over the Irish masses—an oppressive ascendency,
which had caused most of the disorders of the country.
As to religion, there were many Protestants besides
Mr. Parnell himself among the Nationalist leaders.
There was no ill-feeling (except in Ulster) between
Protestants and Roman Catholics in Ireland. There
was no reason to expect that either the Catholic hierarchy
or the priesthood generally would be supreme in an
Irish Parliament, and much reason to expect the contrary.
As regards Ulster, where, no doubt, there were special
difficulties, due to the bitter antagonism of the Orangemen
(not of the Protestants generally) and Catholics,
Mr. Gladstone had undertaken to consider any special
provisions which could be suggested as proper to meet
those difficulties. These replies, however, made
little impression. They were pronounced, and
pronounced all the more confidently the more ignorant
of Ireland the speaker was, to be too hypothetical.
To many Englishmen the case seemed to be one of two
hostile factions contending in Ireland for the last
sixty years, and that the gift of self-government
might enable one of them to tyrannize over the other.
True, that party was the majority, and, according to
the principles of democratic government, therefore