But in the conduct of operations against Lee, there were so many roads open, so many commanders in the field, and so many plans of operations suggested, so many considerations to be observed that no one man except Grant who was clad with special powers for the emergency, could hope for the honor of directing all movements.  That became his exclusive function as soon as he was made Lieutenant General, but unfortunately, as has been shown, he and Smith began drifting apart from the day of their arrival in the East, and long before the great task before them was accomplished they had by their own peculiarities, looking at the problem from different points of view, and aided doubtless by the misrepresentations and selfish purposes of others, become hopelessly out of harmony with each other.

This is not the place to pronounce final judgment between them.  They knew each other well, and although Grant had said towards the close of their friendship, “General Smith, while a very able officer, is obstinate, and is likely to condemn whatever is not suggested by himself,” he had shown an earnest desire that his great talents should be utilized.  On the other hand Smith, who was intimately acquainted with both the strength and the weaknesses of Grant’s character, had full confidence in the soundness of his judgment, when left free from prejudice and misrepresentation, to act upon a full statement of the facts.  Neither had hitherto shown himself to be particularly sensitive to criticism from the other, and both were in the highest degree patriotic and loyal to the cause.  They had worked harmoniously and with marked success together in the West.  Not a shadow had come between them.  The case must therefore have been a most complicated one which made it impossible for them to work together in the same manner and to the same end in the East.  The severance of their relationship, to whatever influence it may be attributed, is profoundly to be regretted, not only because it prematurely ended the military career of General Smith, but because it must have injuriously affected the fortunes of General Grant as well as of the country and the army, at a time when both sorely needed the help of every capable soldier.  These results are all the more to be deplored because no one can study the circumstances connected therewith, without reaching the conclusion that they were brought about by methods which were themselves not above criticism, and which finally resulted in the downfall of their author.

***End of the project gutenberg EBOOK heroes of the great conflict; life and services of William Farrar Smith, major general, united states volunteer in the civil war***

******* This file should be named 14429.txt or 14429.zip *******

This and all associated files of various formats will be found in:  http://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/1/4/4/2/14429