George, on the Niagara, under the command of the junior
lieutenant-colonel, the head quarters being, we believe,
at York, the capital. This officer, it seems,
more by useless annoyance than by actual severity,
had exasperated the men under his command to that
degree that they formed a plot to murder all the officers
present, with the exception of a young man who had
recently joined; and then to cross over to the United
States. Far be it from us to justify the intention,
which indeed was highly criminal; but in all such
extreme cases we hold that a sad abuse of power, or
a gross want of tact, must be the exciting cause,
and that even in the passive obedience of a military
life, there may be a limit to human endurance.
The proximity of the United States rendered this plot
a very feasible one, as the men in a body could have
crossed the river Niagara without molestation or difficulty.
The suspicions of the officer in command having been
aroused, he hastily wrote to Lieut.-Colonel Brock on
the subject, and sent his letter by one of the men,
who delivered it as the latter officer was shooting,
or on his return from a shooting excursion. On
reading the letter, and knowing from the character
of the man that he must be engaged in the conspiracy,
if there were any, he threatened to shoot him on the
spot, if he did not instantly divulge the names of
the ringleaders. The man, thus taken by surprise,
did as he was ordered, and Lieut.-Colonel Brock hurried
off to Fort George. On his arrival he found the
men at dinner, and placing the officers with their
drawn swords at the doors, he went into the rooms
with handcuffs, and secured the most culpable, among
whom was a sergeant, none offering the slightest resistance.
The ringleaders were immediately embarked, so as to
prevent any attempt at their rescue.[18] On being
tried by a court martial, four were condemned to suffer
death, and, with three deserters, were shot at Quebec,
in presence of the garrison, early in the month of
March, 1804. A most awful and affecting sight
it was: the wind was easterly, strong, and cold,—a
thick drift of snow added to the gloom,—and,
as if to increase the horror of the scene, a few of
the firing party, fifty-six in number, instead of
advancing to within eight yards of the prisoners,
as was intended, owing to some mistake commenced firing
at the distance of at least fifty yards. The
consequence was, that the unhappy wretches were only
partially wounded, and dropped one after another.
Nearly forty shots were fired before one poor fellow
in the centre fell, although he was wounded through
the abdomen at the first discharge. The men who
had reserved their fire, were at length ordered up,
and, lodging the contents of their muskets in the
breasts of the culprits, by that means put them out
of torture. The unfortunate sufferers declared
publicly that, had they continued under the command
of Colonel Brock, they would have escaped their melancholy
end; and, as may be easily conceived, he felt no little
anguish that they, who had so recently and so bravely
fought under him in Holland and at Copenhagen, were
thus doomed to end their lives, the victims of unruly
passions inflamed by vexatious authority. He
was now directed to assume the command at Fort George,
and all complaint and desertion instantly ceased.