“Hey!” he cried to Gibson.  “What d’ye think o’ that?”

“God!  It canna be,” muttered Gibson.

And: 

“Aye! That’s gey queer like!” chorused the other shepherds.

What had caught the quick eye of old Hyslop was a fresh brand, or “buist,” on the ewe’s nose; the letter “O” was newly burned there, nearly obliterating an old letter “T.”  The latter was Mr. Gibson’s fire-brand; “O” that of his not distant neighbour, Murdison, tenant in Ormiston.  Gibson and Murdison were on friendly terms, and both were highly respectable and respected farmers.  Necessarily, this discovery anent the brands was most disturbing, and could not fail to be difficult of satisfactory explanation.  Gibson did not wish to act hastily, but all his private investigations pointed only to the one conclusion, and there was no room for doubt that the ewe had been seen by shepherds on other farms making her way across the lofty hills that lie between Newby and Wormiston, as the latter place was locally called.  Still, he hesitated to act in so ugly looking an affair, and it was only after long and painful consultation with a neighbour, himself of late a heavy loser, that Gibson went to Peebles in order to get the authority necessary to enable him to inspect the flocks on Ormiston.

With heavy heart, Gibson, accompanied by Telfer, a well-known Peebles officer of the law, trudged out to Ormiston.  As they neared the farm-house a shepherd, leaning against an outbuilding, turned with a start at sight of them, slipped suddenly round a corner of the outhouse, and presently was seen, bent nearly double, in hot haste running for a field of standing corn.

“Aye! yon’s John Millar awa’.  I’m feared things looks bad,” muttered Gibson to his companion as they approached the door of the farm-house.  “You keep ahint in the onstead, John Telfer, and I’ll get Murdison to come oot.  We’ll never can tell him afore his wife.”

“Wulliam Gibson!  Hoo are ye?  Man, this is a sicht for sair een,” cried Murdison heartily to his visitor.  “Come awa’ in ben, and hae a glass.”

A greeting so friendly brought a lump into Gibson’s throat that he found it hard to swallow.

“Na, I canna come in,” he answered in a low voice; “John Telfer’s ahint the onstead, wantin’ to speak to ye.”

“John Telfer! what can he want wi’ me?” cried Murdison, going grey in the face.  “Oh, aye!  In one minute,” he said, hastily stepping back into the kitchen and whispering a few words to his wife.  Gibson did not hear the words, but his heart sank like lead as he noticed Mrs. Murdison fling herself into a chair, bury her face in her hands, and wail, “Oh God! my heart will break.”

“Alexander Murdison, I hae a warrant here, and I maun hae a bit look at a wheen o’ your sheep,” said the officer of the law when Murdison came with Gibson into the Steading.